No. 36. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…ach, and to keep silent about them. But I must reject the reproach that Dr. Marmorek made in passing, that I spoke with scorn of political Zionism. I could not have spoken of it with scorn, since I was not informed of the official political activity in Zionism; but I shall also be the last to pass over our political labours with a shrug of the shoulders. I regret the excited tone of Herr Marmorek's remarks. In my question I did not mean to express that the political road is not practicable and is not the right one. I only wished to know: does a political activity exist, and if so, what is it? I can understand that one speaks of it only very cautiously, because these are problems of the future. But can you give us the assurance that, on the strength of your credo, we may go on working with easy minds? I ask you, as I ask myself: with what capital will you go before the masses tomorrow to propose Zionism to them? The wheel of our work is turning, but the time might come when the wheel needs new force in order to go on turning. What I demand of you is the new blood, the new word, that will guarantee us the continuance of the work. If you have it not, you may say so without fear; indeed, you must say so. Greenberg told me today that he pictures the work as the boring of a tunnel. One must bore from both sides: from the one side with practical work, from the other with political. I hardly think that anyone here disagrees with this view. There is not a single one who does not wish for a fruitful co-operation of both forces. On the one side, however, among those who demand practical work in Palestine, there is a worked-out programme; there we see proposals, projects and plans. They may in part not be very good, they may be bad, but we do see something positive — attempts, work, and naturally mistakes along with it. On the other side, however, I see only the secret. East and West! You know very well that we Zionists have made this distinction and do not wish to make it. The whole of Zionist tactics has always aimed at building bridges between East and West, and the day when the bridge is built once for all — that day will perhaps mean the solution of the Zionist question! You speak too, Dr. Marmorek, of the lack of homogeneity in the leadership! It was certainly our intention that the leadership should be homogeneous. What is needed, however, is that the heterogeneous elements among us should agree upon a common programme, and that is what the E. A. C. requires. But if every member of the E. A. C. works on his own account, then the man who stands at the head of the E. A. C. must be continually on his guard lest he be caught between the opposing forces. Greenberg, for example, moves far more one-sidedly in one direction than Ussischkin. Greenberg has, it is true, brought in two motions here, but towards them I have almost the feeling with which one receives the gifts of the Danaans. I repeat: on the one side the cards are clear, but on the other they are unclear! They need not be unclear, but they are handled as though only Greenberg knew how to read them. And this opaqueness of our political activity is what might impair our confidence. It is an old piece of wisdom that all diplomatic activity can rest only upon bayonets, upon a force. Where do you look for this force? In our Bank, in the National Fund? Or do you not believe that such a force could be given us by a series of institutions in Palestine, set up and founded according to a uniform political plan? A plan that one might perhaps keep secret, that one does not chatter about. I ask you: can you name to me anything that you conceive of as a force in support of our political work, which I hold to be very valuable? Or do you believe that diplomacy alone suffices? Do you not believe that more attention will be given to our political work if we can point to practical work in Palestine? I do not conceal from myself that there are dangers in practical work. But is this not an enchanted circle? Had we more means, more shekel-payers, we should be a greater power and could negotiate better. But we shall not obtain these means and these shekel-payers if we can show no successes. And do you not feel, too, that the question has become so acute for us that some of us believe they can do nothing better for the movement than to go to Palestine themselves? Dr. Marmorek, have you something else, something new? Then I beg you: out with it! Give me an answer to my question!
Greenberg: I too hold the question which Dr. Weizmann has raised in his speech to be the most important that has yet occupied the Annual Conference. It is already late, but I will nevertheless endeavour to answer it at length. Dr. Weizmann says that I am against Ussischkin. I have always been for practical work in Palestine, but I am against the unpractical. This is the only difference between Ussischkin and me. Further, Dr. Weizmann says that I did not bring in my two resolutions relating to Palestine with the necessary seriousness. I would point out that I suggested the formation of a committee in Palestine at a time when there was as yet no talk of the East Africa project. I say this so that it may be seen how far back this matter goes. In all my political actions I never think of their political effect, but always only of their effect for Palestine. I am not political, but simply a Zionist. Dr. Weizmann asks what we are doing politically? I say that we have not merely hope but also cause to be satisfied with our political work and to achieve much; but I declare again and again that one cannot speak of these matters as openly as is perhaps generally desired. What we need is a stronger support from the people, for only with this can the road we are now travelling politically lead to success.
Feiwel: It is much to be regretted that the question which I said earlier was the fateful question of the movement is only now being raised. When I spoke earlier of a secret resistance to the work in Palestine, Dr. Marmorek rejected the charge. His present speech has shown which of us two was in the right. Now, after Herr Greenberg too has spoken, I must confess that he has given us as little a satisfactory answer as Marmorek's spirited speech has shown us a political system. I do not speak of today's motions, nor of the person of Ussischkin; but Dr. Marmorek put the matter wrongly when he asserted that Ussischkin had betrayed confidence when he let himself be elected to the Actions Committee. Dr. Marmorek surely knows precisely who had the majority at the Congress and on what political programme the Actions Committee was elected. But now to the bogey of Chowewe-Zionism itself. Why all the great noise? What, then, has actually been undertaken practically in Palestine by the Actions Committee since the last Congress? Only reflect! A branch of the Bank has been founded, the "Bezalel" has been founded. What else? On the contrary, in our opinion far too little has been done. We have neglected to make use of the whole immigration and the influx of capital, to stimulate private initiative; we have not only failed to prove ourselves leaders in Palestinian affairs, but have even taken care not to intervene in any way in these significant changes . . . I understand that the Actions Committee cannot speak of all the political steps it undertakes, but on this point we must receive an answer, and a clear answer: how far the Actions Committee is willing to recognise and take into consideration the work in Palestine as a political means. The other political means belong solely to the sphere of the A. C.; to this means, however, the whole Organisation contributes. And this Organisation wishes to co-operate, must co-operate.
Warburg: I withdraw my motion. For the rest, I believe I need not go further into the remarks of Feiwel and Weizmann. We believe, at all events, that we are just as good political Zionists as Herr Marmorek and his friends. For this we appeal to Dr. Herzl, who himself began practical work in Palestine. At that time the plans were not yet practicable, and if we carry them out today, one therefore has no right to say that it is not political.
Sokolow: On one point I will speak otherwise than Messrs. Feiwel and Weizmann. We ought not to demand clarity, but to give clarity. The position of Zionism is difficult because its centre of gravity lies, after all, in Russia, and there, in view of the depression in Jewry, the Organisation must be especially supported. Purely diplomatic-political Zionism — one must not deceive oneself about this — no longer suffices today as programme and method. Views on tactics are now quite different. One must therefore, in this situation too, proceed politically and practically at once. What is now the main thing, the maintenance and strengthening of the Zionist Organisation, must not be lost sight of. That this may come about, something radical must be undertaken, something living; present-day work must be accomplished. It is a question here neither of small nor of large colonisation, nor is it a question of whether this or that Minister has promised something to this or that person. The main thing is life and the steady current in the Organisation.
Dr. Lewin: We have not become unfaithful to political Zionism. But to you, Doctor Marmorek, has the Palestine-
2*