Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 38 · 19 September 1906
7printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 38 — "Die Welt" — 7

(continued from page 6)

...carried off. The Poles? Oh no, they could not have won the victory by their own strength. But there is yet another class of Jews who, without any sense of their own interests, without any understanding of social connections, sacrifice their last and best upon the altar of Polish assimilation. For in the electoral contest between the Zionists and the "Poles" the national element was not alone decisive. It was not merely the Jew Stand who was to enter Parliament, — but the democrat. The victory of the Zionists would have meant the victory of democratic, free men over the domineering, enslaving and servile Schlachta; the victory of the Zionists would at the same time have been the victory of an oppressed people over its oppressors. For the Poles are the masters in Galicia — Jews and Ruthenians are their servants. This social significance the election of the Zionist might have attained, — had the neck of our "intelligent" Jewish middle class in Galicia not been bowed so low, had they, who expire in reverence — and perhaps in simple fear — before the Poles, also possessed some understanding of their own time.

THE PALESTINE CONFERENCE AT FRANKFORT-ON-MAIN

At the invitation of the "Pekidim and Amarkalim" of the Palestinian communities at Amsterdam, there met at Frankfort-on-Main on the 11th inst. a conference of friends of the Holy Land from all circles of orthodox Jewry, in order, as the letter of invitation put it, to subject the organisation of the so-called Amsterdam Chaluka to a fresh examination, and above all to ascertain what economic and religious results the Chaluka has achieved in the Holy Land, and what might perhaps be done to realise the intentions underlying it in an ever more perfect manner, one excluding every abuse. The impulse for the conference had come from South German friends of Erez Israel, who accordingly appeared in considerable numbers. But the North, as well as other countries, was also represented by persons of standing. The order of the day ran as follows:

  1. "The historical development and the organisation of the Chaluka." Speaker: Rabbi A. S. Onderwyzer, Amsterdam.
  2. "The future tasks of the Chaluka and the means for accomplishing them." Speaker: Mr. Jakob Rosenheim, Frankfort-on-Main.
  3. Open discussion.
  4. Preparatory measures for the regular dispatch of commissions of inquiry to Palestine.

Shortly after three o'clock the proceedings were opened in the lecture hall of the Isr. Religionsgesellschaft by the President of the Pekidim, M. S. Rubens jr., of Amsterdam, who greeted those present in warm words and handed the chair to Rabbi Dr. S. Breuer of Frankfort-on-Main. The Chairman pointed out by way of introduction that the purpose of the conference was, first, to set forth before a wider public the development and the fundamental principles of this much-misunderstood institution, and then also to single out, from the mass of complaints often raised out of ignorance, those points which might prove serviceable in an organic further development and possible reshaping of the Chaluka. Above all it must be held fast that we are in no case entitled to introduce any changes recognised as necessary without thorough consultation with the appointed rabbinical leaders of the Jewry of Jerusalem. Thereupon the first speaker, Rabbi Onderwyzer of Amsterdam, Secretary of the Pekidim and Amarkalim, took the floor for his address:

The Historical Development and the Organisation of the Chaluka

The speaker's remarks set out from the collections for Palestine reaching back to Talmudic times, and then described how, throughout the whole of the Middle Ages, the Palestinian emissaries were everywhere in the Diaspora received with open arms, like "brothers from the distant common home of our fathers." The administration now existing in Amsterdam may regard the year 1809 as the date of its birth. From the recognition that the system of emissaries occasioned disproportionate costs, the sole collection and administration of the Erez Israel moneys was at that time entrusted to three Amsterdam men of high repute, Goedeinde, Prins and Lehren. The distribution itself caused no difficulty at that period, because there was in Jerusalem only one community, and that not very considerable in numbers, consisting almost exclusively of Sefardim. The immigration into Palestine from "Ashkenazic" lands (that is, Russia and Western Europe), however, very soon received a substantial increase, so that as early as the year 1824, on grounds of equity, a substantial part of the moneys — coming for the most part from Holland and Germany — had to be assigned to the German-Dutch immigrant body, which had meanwhile grown into a community, and to the East European one. From that time on, after Rabbi Hirsch Lehren, with unexampled devotion, had created a comprehensive and exemplary organisation for the collection of the moneys, the problem of distribution became ever more difficult and intricate. While on the one hand, on purely human as well as halachic considerations, the Dutch-German community undoubtedly had a moral claim to special consideration, the more so as its members received no support whatever from any other (Russian, Hungarian, Galician, etc.) Chaluka, yet on the other hand the enormous numerical preponderance of the immigrants from Eastern Europe, despite their own Chaluka, and the historically older rights of the Sefardim (who, after all, had given up the system of emissaries in view of the Amsterdam Chaluka) likewise demanded attention. One result of these variously directed considerations is the so-called Pescher, i. e. the key according to which the receipts are distributed among the individual "Kollim." It has been revised several times in accordance with the circumstances of the time, and was last fixed in 1896 in such a way that 45—48% of the receipts fall to the Dutch-German community, and about 55% to the other communities. While in the case of the first-named community, with its 200 souls, the share of each individual family is exactly determined by the Pekidim themselves, and those who may no longer be in need of support are, as a matter of course, excluded to the best of their knowledge and conscience, in the case of the other communities, with their 30—40000 souls, whose circumstances cannot possibly be surveyed, nothing else can be done from Amsterdam than to transmit the quota falling to the individual communities to their heads for further distribution — without any participation on the part of the Amsterdam administration. The speaker then gives a detailed account of the procedure of remittance and distribution in the Dutch-German Chaluka. Upon the private life of the beneficiaries the Amsterdam Chaluka administration exerts no influence; in particular it has never yet deprived anyone of his share in the Chaluka for transgressing the Cherem resting upon the European schools in Jerusalem. On the other hand, however, it likewise refuses to compel those under its protection to disregard that בי״ד. The speaker closes with a warm-hearted description of the works of genuinely Jewish charity effected through the Chaluka.

The floor is now given to Mr. Jakob Rosenheim of Frankfort-on-Main for the second address:

The Future Tasks of the Chaluka and the Means for Accomplishing Them.

The speaker dealt thoroughly with the economic results of the Chaluka in view of the positively rapid shifts in the number and composition of the population that have taken place during the last century; further, with the question whether and to what extent the Chaluka has stifled the spirit of self-help; and finally with the legal conditions for any changes that may be undertaken. It is gratifying, he said, that the great economic importance of the Chaluka and its immense historical merit have in recent times at last been gratefully acknowledged even from the Zionist side, formerly hostile. Passing to the mode of distribution of the Amsterdam Chaluka in particular, the speaker discusses the census lists of the כולל הו״ד lying before him, and comes to the conclusion that, while an improvement of the method of inquiry is possible here, it would be highly unreasonable to shake the principle of sparing at least a small number of families complete proletarianisation.

The case is otherwise with the "provision" for the "remainder" of the population by the Amsterdam Chaluka! There 32000 Fr. are frittered away on some 30—40000 souls, without any appreciable advantage accruing to the individual in 90 per cent. of the cases, — for what are sums of one franc a year per head to signify, even in the most wretched circumstances?

Quite contrary, therefore, to the opinion often expressed that one

2*