Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 39 · 28 September 1906
32printed page
scan 30 of 32

"Die Welt" — No. 39.

(continued from page 31)

…can be remedied, and if the members of this Company were restricted to the persons who wish to act as Trustees and Managers of the Fund, then no one appears to take upon himself a greater liability than is borne by Trustees of a Trust Deed."

It will be seen from this that the members of the A. C., or those persons who would have formed the proposed Trust Company, had no reason to let themselves be turned away from this form of legalisation by the fact that an unlimited liability would exist, for this was only the ordinary position of Trustees. But the further statement was made that, should an operation have to be undertaken entailing liability not covered by the existing funds of the institution, subsidiary companies could be founded with limited liability (as was the case with the Anglo-Palestine Company), which would relieve the Trust Company and the members composing it of any joint or personal risk. The power to form such subsidiary companies, together with the right to pursue its own limited operations, such as the acquisition of land, would have enabled the N. F. to take part in and carry out all regular operations within the scope even of the resolutions of the VI. Congress, so far as such were necessary for the exercise of the principal object; but even this did not satisfy those who had attached themselves to the plan of the company with limited liability, and this Conference has to decide whether they have acted wisely in abandoning the proposal of a Trust in any form (either by registered deed or by an incorporated company) and insisting upon the constitution of a trading company in the form now before us. For the purpose of a final decision in this matter it may well serve as a guide, for the Conference and perhaps also for those individual persons upon whom the establishment of the alternative Trust Company would devolve, to bear in mind the following authoritative statements, which find expression in one of the most important books on such matters (Smith's Mercantile Law):

"On registration the subscribers of the Memorandum of Association, together with any other persons who become members, form a body corporate.

As individual partners they assume no personal liability towards third persons in respect of the engagements. The corporation alone can be sued in respect of its debts and its engagements, and the members can only be compelled to contribute in liquidation, either in consequence of a call by the directors while the company is in existence, or by a call which reaches them as contributories in a liquidation. If the existing members are not in a position to raise the contributions which are to be made, then persons who within the course of a year before the commencement of the liquidation have ceased to be members can, for contribution towards the covering of debts or liabilities which were incurred by the company before they ceased to be members.

The directors of a registered company have no liabilities towards third persons and are only bound to contribute by virtue of their membership. (Pages 106 and 107)."

Finally I remark that, should the fear or threat regarding liability be discussed or relied upon in order to influence the decisions of the Conference or of the A. C., which are directly entrusted with the responsibility for the legalisation of the Fund, a word of warning becomes necessary regarding the acceptance of such proposals as they indeed have, for the purpose of creating the proposed company with limited liability, and regarding the handing over of the 50000 £ already collected for the purpose of exercising the right to deal with it under the greatly extended powers and unheard-of objects, as these are indicated and sanctioned by this new constitution.

If any risk exists regarding the future operations of a Trust Company incorporated with strictly limited powers, then they will be as nothing in comparison with the imminent danger of claims which would arise out of matters that would be nothing less than an actual breach of trust, if the considerable sum already collected were given up to be used for purposes which are not covered by the published proposals and on the strength of which the agitation for the N. F. has taken place.

I again draw attention to the express reservations and conditions contained in the first opinion of Mr. Armitslead; but beyond these I am able once more to appeal to the great authority of Dr. Bodenheimer, which authority also found expression with regard to this phase of the matter at the time when he contradicted Dr. Herzl, as indicated before.

If it is now asserted that we had no right to restrict in any way the statement of the objects, of objects which (even if in an irregular manner) at a session of the Congress at that time, a fortiori, then we have no power to enlarge or extend these objects. If a danger exists, it lies in that direction and not in the adoption of any safeguards, also restrictions, which this Conference would adopt in its anxiety to protect the Fund.

I appeal to the Conference at least not to take this responsibility upon itself, but to reject the proposed incorporation of the N. F. in the untenable and insecure form of a company with limited liability. I request the Conference now to decide once and for all, to fix the true character of the J. N. F., and to give it the secure and more fitting constitution of a Trust, either by means of a Trust Deed in connection with the Jewish Colonial Bank or by the founding of a Trust Company as a separate but associated institution.


Dr. Bodenheimer's co-report will appear in the next number.


The Editors' Letter-Box.

L. Gottfried and many correspondents: Information about the Palestine Syndicate, the Plantation Society and all Palestine matters will be given you by the Commission for the Exploration of Palestine, Berlin W, Uhlandstraße 175.


Hamburg, 24th September 1906.

The Hamburg-America Line reports:

  • S.S. Alesia, on the homeward voyage from Eastern Asia, passed Gibraltar 23rd Sept.
  • " Ambria, on the homeward voyage from Eastern Asia, left Havre on the night of 22nd Sept.
  • " Amerika, at New York 22nd September, 9 a.m.
  • " Andalusia, in the Elbe 22nd Sept., 3 p.m.
  • " Artemisia, for Philadelphia, passed Prawle Point 23rd September, 5.45 p.m.
  • " Assyria, coming from the West Indies, in the Elbe 24th September, 6.45 a.m.
  • " Batavia, for New York, passed Dover 23rd September, 3 p.m.
  • " Blücher, for New York, passed the Lizard 22nd September, 5.30 p.m.
  • " Bosnia, at Boston 22nd September, 8 a.m.
  • " Calabria, for the West Indies, passed Ponta Doarnel 22nd Sept.
  • " Dacia, left Manila 24th September, 6 a.m.
  • " Georgia, coming from Galveston, in the Elbe 23rd September, 10.35 p.m.
  • " Graf Waldersee, left New York 22nd Sept., 10 a.m., for Hamburg via Plymouth and Cherbourg.
  • " Hellas, at St. Thomas 23rd September.
  • " Hispania, coming from the West Indies, passed Prawle Point 23rd September, 10 a.m.
  • " Kaiserin Auguste Viktoria, in the Elbe 22nd September, 2 p.m.
  • " La Plata, for North Brazil, passed Cuxhaven 23rd September, 1 p.m.
  • " Macedonia, coming from the La Plata, left Funchal 23rd September, 11 a.m.
  • " Moltke, from New York for Genoa, at Naples 23rd Sept., 2.30 p.m.
  • " Pontos, at Santos 22nd September.
  • " Prinz Oskar, left Genoa for the La Plata 22nd September, 4.30 p.m.
  • " Rhaetia, for Central Brazil, left Lisbon 22nd September, 10 a.m.
  • " Rhenania, on the outward voyage to Eastern Asia, passed Quessant Creach 23rd September.
  • " Savoia, for Persia, passed Dover 24th September, 7 a.m.
  • " Scandia, left Hongkong 22nd September.
  • " Schaumburg, for the West Indies, left Antwerp 23rd September.
  • " Senegambia, left Moji 23rd September, 6 a.m.
  • " Sevilla, coming from New Orleans, passed Dover 23rd Sept., 2.30 p.m.
  • " Sicilia, at Mascat 23rd September.
  • " Sparta, at Santos 23rd September.
  • " St. Jan, coming from Mexico and the West Indies, left Corunna 23rd September, 8 a.m.
  • " Suevia, left Yokohama 23rd September, afternoon.