Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 41 · 12 October 1906
13printed page
scan 11 of 16

No. 41 — "Die Welt" — Page 13.

(continued from page 12)

...whom the land is to be leased were restricted to poor and needy Jews; this, however, is not the case, and, as we hear, it is not intended either that it should be so. It is indeed evident that, in view of the Zionist movement, it will be of great importance rather to favour the settlement of Jewish families of means in Palestine than to regard the land as one in which needy Jews receive shelter out of charity. 'We conclude, therefore, that the purpose of the Fund is far more a political than a charitable one, and that a restriction of the application of the Fund to strictly charitable purposes would contradict the chief purpose of the Fund."

In accordance with this opinion the experts advised a company limited by guarantee, or, if that were preferred, a company with unlimited liability of the members.

On the strength of this opinion Mr. Bentwich now dropped the plan of a "Trust Deed" and advocated a company with unlimited liability. Because of the difficulty, in view of the great responsibility, of finding suitable persons for such a company, this company was to confine itself solely to the keeping and administration of money, but to have the right to form subsidiary companies for the particular purposes of the National Fund as need arose. At Mr. Bentwich's wish a further consultation on this proposal took place with the experts Parker and Warmington. They, however, after hearing my objections and the objections of Mr. Lewis, pronounced decidedly against such a plan. (Compare page 41 of the Materials.)

After this thorough examination of the matter, the National Fund Commission, in agreement with the Inner Actions Committee, thought it right, in accordance with the proposals of all the experts and on the basis of the resolutions of the earlier Commissions and Annual Conferences, to constitute the National Fund as a company with limited liability.

Mr. Lewis has given instructions accordingly. There now lies before you the draft of a Memorandum and of the Articles in accordance with our repeated consultations.

After all these proceedings we could be of the opinion that Mr. Bentwich too would agree to this plan. But since Mr. Bentwich in his report seeks to support the idea he advocates on new grounds, it is necessary to deal with this in a few words.

Mr. Bentwich started from what is in my judgment an erroneous view from the outset, namely that on the basis of the resolutions of the Fifth Congress a "Trust Deed" would be admissible, but not on the basis of the resolutions of the Sixth Congress, which extended the purposes of the National Fund.

He had therefore already advised me in London to legalise the National Fund on the basis of the resolutions of the Fifth Congress and to disregard the resolutions of the Sixth Congress, since they represent an inadmissible extension of the original idea of the National Fund.

After I had flatly rejected this proposal on the basis of the instructions given at the time to Dr. Kokesch and myself, Mr. Bentwich returns to this point by asserting that the Sixth Congress proceeded incorrectly in passing its resolution on the purpose of the National Fund, and that this resolution is consequently invalid. On this the following is to be remarked:

Point 2, which was laid before the Congress, read:

"The purpose of the National Fund shall be the following: In Palestine and the neighbouring countries to buy or to sell building, arable and garden land as well as forests and real estate of every kind, to have the land purchased built upon and worked, or else to lease it to Jews with the exclusion of sub-letting, to found or promote all possible or conceivable undertakings which serve this purpose, to conclude contracts of every kind for the maintenance or acquisition of property for the furtherance of this purpose, and to enter into relations with industrial or financial undertakings as well as with Governments or authorities for the development of this purpose."

After Dr. Farbstein had delivered his report, in which the purpose of the National Fund was also contained, a discussion took place on this point which, as the Minutes show, lasted about five hours. Towards the close of the discussion Dr. Tschlenow proposed that the purpose of the National Fund should not be put to the vote before agreement had been reached on the principle of legalisation and on the seat of the company. At the beginning of the night sitting which followed, the National Fund Commission accordingly withdrew its motion on the matter. Thereupon, after a short discussion and with an exceedingly large participation of the delegates, the vote took place on the individual points proposed to the Congress.

Now that the Congress had resolved by a large majority that the determination of the purpose of the National Fund should not be left to the National Fund Commission, but was to be resolved by the Congress itself, the President was in loyalty obliged to bring about a vote on the purpose of the National Fund also.

Further motions were then put on this point, in particular to exclude the sale of lands, and the purpose, with the adoption of this last amendment, was resolved by the Congress almost unanimously.

It takes great boldness, in this state of affairs, to wish to construe an invalidity of this resolution. It is noteworthy that during this whole debate, in which, among others, Dr. J. W. Marmorek also spoke against the principle of the foundation (see page 278 of the Congress Minutes), Mr. Bentwich did not once take the floor on the question of the National Fund. (Interjection by Bentwich: Was not against it!)

If Mr. Bentwich, as he asserts, was not present at this sitting, he can derive from that no right to deduce the invalidity of the Congress resolution from his own misunderstanding of the proceedings.

But what is the purpose of this whole attack on the resolution of the Sixth Congress at all? The experts Parker and Warmington make no distinction whatever between the purposes of the Fifth and those of the Sixth Congress. They declare quite simply that the purpose of the National Fund, according to the whole character of the Zionist movement, is to be regarded as a political one. The experts would be able to regard the purpose as a charitable one in the sense of English law if the land to be purchased were intended only for poor Jews who are to be settled upon it. But since the resolution of the Fifth Congress designates the National Fund as a property of the Jewish people, without its being intended exclusively for poor Jews, the two points adduced by the experts in no way apply to the National Fund even under the resolutions of the Fifth Congress.

Since, therefore, the creation of a "Trust Deed" is in all circumstances inadmissible, one surely cannot expect us to set the National Fund upon a stool with two legs, so that it must infallibly collapse.

Mr. Bentwich's plan, moreover, is wholly inexplicable to me as a lawyer. Mr. Bentwich speaks so much in his report of the responsibility which one assumes in the legalisation of the National Fund; but then I must say that if I myself, as an English jurist, were of Mr. Bentwich's opinion and were convinced that under English law the arrangement of a "Trust Deed" was admissible, and if even a single English jurist of repute were to pronounce against this form, I should have serious misgivings about advising my client to choose this form of foundation, since it would after all not be out of the question that after 40—50 years, the time at which such a "Trust" reaches its end, an English judge might concur in this opinion of my opponent. Here, however, all six experts consulted, apart from Mr. Bentwich, have pronounced against the principle accepted by Mr. Bentwich. It should therefore be understandable if I most urgently recommend you to give your assent to the principle proposed by me on behalf of the Commission and in agreement with the Solicitor of the Bank, Mr. Lewis.

I have accordingly only to explain in a word wherein the essential differences of this proposal from the draft previously submitted consist.

It is first to be remarked that the holders of the Founder Shares of the Bank are proposed as members of the company. We have therefore considered it superfluous, with so small a number of members, to interpose the organ of a Supervisory Board between the General Meeting and the Directorate, and have accordingly dropped the Supervisory Board. In order, however, to create a brake upon any over-hasty actions of the Directorate, the Inner Actions Committee has been granted the right of veto against the resolutions of the Directorate. This right of veto is formulated in more detail in §§ 26 and 27 of the draft. Further, at the 7th Congress a resolution was passed concerning the power to purchase land, with the reservation that the Actions Committee, with regard to the legal securing of the property acquired, sufficient