Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 41 · 12 October 1906
10printed page
scan 8 of 16

10 — "Die Welt" — No. 41

(continued from page 9)

…to call forth "indignation." This manner of justifying the attack upon us has an amusing effect. With equal right the Rabbinical Union might be assailed, to cite but one example, because no "storm of indignation" was kindled within it when years ago a very worthy member made the ill-considered proposal to buy off the Galician traffickers in girls with capital. — If one will look for storms of indignation, there has been no lack of serious occasions for them either! Where was the storm of indignation among "the appointed representatives of German Jewry, the leading personalities who set the tone," when a Geiger pleaded for the recognition of civil rights against the Zionists, — where, when Jews in the daily press advocated the expulsion of Jews?!

Dr. Vogelstein has used his sharpest weapon. — With it he has censured all the "dangers for Jewry as a whole" which his prophetic eye discerns. He now turns to the therapy: how is one to combat the wicked Zionism which spreads more and more and is constantly growing in influence and strength?

This section is of lesser interest to us. We think that the attempts to combat us will, now as before, be for us a source of that calm cheerfulness which the creative worker needs. We shall take good care not to set forth why this or that remedy is absurd or misconceived. Dr. Vogelstein has put forward a new remedy, which he warmly recommends to the "Liberals," — the boycott of those of his colleagues who think otherwise about Zionism. He knows that the new generation of rabbis, — and not only the new one, — is almost without exception staunchly Zionist, and he demands that the honourable heads of congregations make strictest abstinence from Zionism a condition of appointment for rabbinical candidates. In other words: Dr. Vogelstein threatens the young colleagues whose Zionist views he knows with breadlessness, should they not obey orders! All honour to such Liberalism! —

It is not for us in this place to guard the dignity of the rabbinical profession! — Even should the "storm of indignation" not arise in rabbinical circles and liberal circles, we shall take care not to draw conclusions against a whole body from this grotesque proposal of an individual.

And even Dr. Vogelstein we will not hold too much to blame for these last somewhat strong attacks. Immediately afterwards we are almost wholly mollified again when we see the text of the protest of 1898 printed. — That is the old Storm-Comrade, — that is the orthodox, letter-believing Reform rabbi. Thus it stands written, — the Word they still shall let remain! — And though of our old prayers not one verse is left standing beside another, — this protest remains the sanctuary, the inviolable word of Dr. Maybaum! (or who was the author at that time?)

One must bear in mind that this protest was published by the committee in 1897, before the first Congress, that is, before the creation of the Zionist programme at all, — that the general meeting of 1898 then did not wish to disavow those 5 gentlemen, that to-day there are hardly two or three rabbis who do not confidentially admit that a colossal blunder was committed at that time — in order rightly to appreciate the greatness and guilelessness of Dr. Vogelstein.

The old Storm-Comrade! Ought we not to make many allowances for him? For him and for many of his generation! They had their ideals and believed in their right, — history has passed them by, — the other generation is slipping out from under their hands, — other ways! And they cling to their old banner, which no one has followed this long while, and shout, — and want to stem the stream of life. — How the "Old Man of the Mountain" in Sudermann rebukes them, — he too one of the old generation, but one who has kept his clear understanding:

"Are you going to keep up the row much longer? Look, as we sit here, we were once ... young and strong. . . . We couldn't imagine the way of the world any other way at all than as we had fixed it up for ourselves. But then one came along who was stronger than us. He knocked us all of a heap. And with it not only our prestige and our bit of (points to his forehead) with it our character too went to pieces. Have you still got the courage to believe in your right? . . . Ideas without a master are as useless as dogs without a master, whole men must stand behind them. Else the Devil takes them. . . . Now that one was a different sort of fellow. . . . Now the world goes its way. And we must go along. We — must — go — along! . . . So make your peace!"

So speaks the Old Man of the Mountain. — And Storm-Comrade Spinoza repeats it after him, the word of peace. — But Storm-Comrade Vogelstein? — Who knows!


THE POSITION OF THE GERMAN JEWS IN POLITICS

By Dr. Carl Kassel (Posen)

Of late the phrase "Jewish politics" has frequently been heard. In another form all the strivings to which politics is meant to lead have condensed into the creation of a "Jewish centre," "a Jewish faction." It is less the indignation with which Dr. Vogelstein "calmly and objectively" — Wippchen, stand by me! — annihilates Zionism, and with which he discusses the political question, that prompts a discussion of this point, than rather the fact that much unclearness prevails in the ranks of the Jews about their political significance and attitude, and further in this, that from this unclearness many a misunderstanding prevails with regard to coinages such as "Jewish politics," "Jewish faction," etc.

For our endeavours, since we live after all in the world of realities and not in Cloud-Cuckoo-Land, we must take the situation of the Jews as it is and will remain for a very long time: socially proscribed, politically betrayed, precisely by the bourgeois parties of the Left, whose props the Jewish masses have always been and unhappily still are to-day. It is told that