No. 41 — "Die Welt" — 9
(continued from page 8)
…is, he says, an "artificial construction." — To refute this argument is almost impossible without becoming banal. Have we not had to say the same thing countless times! — I will be brief: the German Nationals of Austria are not bad Austrian citizens, the German-Americans not the worst citizens of the United States. Prussia is made up of many stocks, and each stock is proud of its history, — by stressing our nationality we shall not make it harder for ourselves to be good Prussian citizens, — sincere and upright ones! — That we do not wish to lead the whole body of German Jews out of the country should be well known. That we feel ourselves at one with our kinsmen, especially in their distress, is our damned duty and obligation.
Be it well understood! We rejoice that no conflict exists between our Jewish duties and our duties as citizens. Should we find such a conflict, we shall confess it freely and openly and see how we might escape the sad dilemma. We cannot, however, imagine such a case. But in no event do we seek artificially to bridge a gulf. —
But we rightly call it an "artificial construction" when the descendants of Abraham, Isaac and Israel are stamped as descendants of Hermann and Thusnelda, as members of an alien nation.
Now Dr. Vogelstein finds it awkward that the Zionist Delegates' Conference sends its telegram of homage to the German Emperor every year; therein, he says, lies a certain admission that the patriotism is not so very much to boast of after all. — Seek faithfully, and thou shalt find a point of attack. This deduction, I believe, is at least new. It is surely measuring with a very unequal measure, when one considers that almost every annual assembly standing on patriotic ground expresses its attachment to the Empire in the same way. — Certainly we have not had occasion, as the Rabbinical Assembly, for instance, has had, to prove the strength of our attachment by a telegram renewed every year in spite of the absence of any reply, — but for that the fault surely does not lie with us! — Yes, says Dr. Vogelstein, but with such a telegram the Zionists set themselves up as representatives of the whole of German Jewry. That seems quite puzzling. Has it not, for instance, already been clearly expressed by the absence of any reply to other Jewish telegrams that a distinction is very well drawn between the Zionists and others? How in all the world can one reproach us with sailing under a false flag, with not showing ourselves openly as what we are? Our programme, our meetings, our reports and balance-sheets lie before the public, — it must really be hard to find weapons against us when one resorts to such accusations, refuted by notorious facts, — when one at last plays off the authority of Eduard von Hartmann against us.
I truly do not wish to dwell longer on this chapter; we had occasion only recently, in connection with Professor Geiger's attacks, to discuss the matter. One would not think it possible that to-day, after Zionism has for nearly a decade put forth blossoms and fruits, — after it has become evident that all the prophecies and apprehensions uttered at its cradle from the hostile side have come to nought, — that one should still come at us to-day with the stalest of old arguments. Where in these 10 years has a slackening of love of country taken place among the Zionists? — Where have serious Christians ever reproached Jewry with lack of patriotism on account of Zionism? — Where has a government, a monarch, even by misunderstanding, shown the Zionist Jews more mistrust than the others? I could easily enough prove the very opposite, — could name witnesses from well-nigh every country under the sun, — but to what end? Whoever has followed events knows how matters stand. Whoever still raises reproaches against us in this direction to-day does so either because he knows nothing of the matter or because he wishes to know nothing of it.
For it is really hard, in what follows of the author's exposition, to keep one's conviction of his good faith. Happily we know that Dr. Vogelstein is the writer, and so there can be no ill will. In a long section, the sharpest and most heated of the whole pamphlet, the author turns against a motion put forward at the last Delegates' Conference of the German Zionists, to the effect that the Central Committee should initiate the founding of a national-Jewish territorial organisation in Germany. Here the author's wrath discharges itself in rugged fashion, — here he raises a mighty fire-alarm, — this motion he takes as the starting-point for his call to defence. And now one must know that this is the one motion brought before the Delegates' Conference which gave occasion for no resolution and scarcely for a debate. — Indeed, the Central Committee itself took the opportunity, in answer to a misleading newspaper article in a hostile paper, to declare publicly that it does not share the standpoint of the mover! — And that is the Rabbi's weapon with which he draws back for the annihilating blow. — Not our programme, not a resolution of any Congress is found made the object of criticism in the pamphlet, — but a proposal brought in at a territorial assembly and rejected. A better document for the position of our programme and our Congresses, raised above all attacks, is scarcely to be found!
To speak of the justification of that motion is superfluous after the unequivocal stand of the German territorial federation. But that Dr. Vogelstein is also vexed at the national-Jewish faction in the Duma is too characteristic to be passed over in silence. He seems to wish that even there the Jews had appeared masked as National Russians or National Poles, so that Messrs. Winawer and Lewin would there have suppressed their speeches on the pogroms, as their Jewish colleagues in the Prussian Diet did on a similar occasion.
Dr. Vogelstein knows that the motion was not raised to a resolution, — but nevertheless he feels himself entitled to his conclusions and attacks, because the motion called forth no storm of indignation. I do not wish to inquire whether this motion was really of a kind, anywhere and in any way,