No. 45 — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
At its Bruenn Party Congress in September 1899 the Austrian Social Democracy unanimously adopted five "guiding principles" for the purpose of "the final settlement of the question of nationalities and languages in Austria in the spirit of equal right." According to the stenographic minutes, these principles, which are preceded among other things by the statement that "the cultivation and development of the national individuality of all the peoples of Austria is possible only on the basis of equal right," read as follows:
- Austria is to be transformed into a democratic federal state of nationalities.
- In place of the historic crown lands there shall be formed nationally delimited self-governing bodies, whose legislation and administration shall be conducted by national chambers elected on the basis of universal, equal and direct suffrage.
- All the administrative territories of one and the same nation together form a nationally unified association, which conducts its national affairs with complete autonomy.
- The right of the national minorities shall be safeguarded by a special law to be enacted by the Imperial Parliament.
- We recognize no national privilege, and therefore reject the demand for a state language; how far a common language of intercourse is necessary, an Imperial Parliament will determine.
Since the late lamented "Sole Leader" in Russia, and likewise the "Separatists," have repeatedly appealed to this programme in their humbug about "cultural" autonomy, and since it must accordingly be assumed that they simply do not understand German, let something also be quoted here from the commentaries which, according to the said minutes, Seliger and Nemec gave in the name of the programme committee. Seliger: "Nemec said yesterday that when we speak here of autonomous national self-governing territories, the question is not thereby settled how these self-governing territories are to be administered in economic respects. It became evident yesterday that a clear expression for this is lacking. In order to indicate it here, we have expressly declared that the nationally delimited administrative bodies are now to take the place of the historic crown lands, that is to say, with roughly the same functions as are at present assigned to the crown lands; that, for example, the self-governing territory of German Bohemia is to be combined with the other self-governing territories of German tongue in Austria into one unified association." With regard to those minorities which, like, for example, the Germans, live in communes lying within the Czech "self-governing territory," and vice versa, Seliger states that a future democratic parliament will have to enact a special law for these minorities and their national interests.
Nemec: "The existing provincial boundaries will be torn down and natural national boundaries formed. The national territories will take the place of the existing crown lands."
And now, for a closer understanding, something from the debate, likewise according to the stenographic minutes. Speaker for the motion Hankiewicz (Ruthenian, Lemberg): "If one is of the opinion that Social Democracy has to further weak nations in their development, then it is necessary that each of these nations . . . should if possible have a territory of its own, where as an autonomous national unit it can truly develop all these forces." Speaker for the motion Pernersdorfer: "We wish to secure the existence of the nations in their territories. I myself, indeed, stand upon the ground of the proposals of Synopticus (the author of the well-known pamphlet in which national autonomy for Austria is demanded without regard to territory). . . . Unfortunately, however, I do not see the possibility of carrying them out in practice. . . . There is no securing of a nation except by fixing definite national territories . . . and that is done by our wishing to see the dominion of each nation confined to a certain territory. Naturally it will then also be necessary to organize a reasonable protection of the minorities. . . ."
Speaker against the motion Kristan (South Slav, Trieste): "The Executive demands national territories, we demand national autonomy without regard to territory. . . . The be-all and end-all of this question is how equality of rights is to be brought about. If one creates a formation which of necessity encloses minorities within itself, equality of rights cannot be attained, all the less so as the fluctuations in the population will not cease for a long time to come. . . . We must establish as a principle that equality of rights is to be brought about if the nation is not a population living on a piece of land, but the sum of all those persons who profess themselves of one nation. . . . The resolution of the Executive is unacceptable to me also because it once more creates something like a kind of new vested possession. Nor is the point about the protection of minorities exactly congenial to me. . . ."
Speaker against the motion Ellenbogen: "If certain territories are assigned to the nationalities as their home, then we must also speak of the minorities of other tongues, . . . and the national quarrel begins all over again. . . . We must find another form here, and declare from the outset that we do not hold fast to the principle of the territoriality of nations, but pass over to the spheres of national corporations without territories, which are formed on the basis of voluntary profession and which then regulate their linguistic and cultural affairs in complete autonomy, on the basis of universal, equal and direct suffrage, in their national curiae. If we obtain these national curiae, every quarrel about schools, etc., ceases, because such matters no longer concern the Parliament and the Government."
And finally, speaker against the motion Vanek (Budweis): "We now have provincial boundaries, and if we wish to create national territories we must form new boundaries . . . it can easily happen that a minority suddenly becomes a majority . . . so it seems to me more reasonable, after all, that we disregard the provincial boundaries entirely and found national communities after the pattern of the religious communities. . . ."
As has been said, the theses of the committee, which demand a territorial-national autonomy, were — for tactical reasons — adopted unanimously.
I have quoted at some length, not only because here for the first time the problem of national autonomy is exhaustively discussed, but because our views on national autonomy almost coincide with those of the speakers against the motion.
If, however, the Separatists and Bundists talk of a "cultural" autonomy and in so doing appeal to the programme of the Austrian Social Democracy, then, according to the commentary of the speakers for the motion, they would logically have had to wait until the Jews possess the majority in Palestine or somewhere else upon a territory; for only there would they then have a claim to the national-territorial autonomy of the Social Democrats.
Of a merely cultural autonomy the above programme does not speak at all, evidently for the reason that the "national chambers," if they were assigned all the functions of the present crown lands, would also have to embrace economic institutions and undertakings, as at present, for example, in Lower Austria, the provincial railways, insurance institutions, and so forth. For side by side with the tendency toward nationalization by the State there is also a kind of tendency toward provincial change.
What such an autonomy, in which for want of a territory they would have no share, would mean for the Jews, we already know well enough from experience of the present partial autonomy of the provinces. The Galician Provincial School Board and the Galician Provincial Committee are deterrent examples in both cultural and economic respects. And even if the "national chambers" should take on a more democratic character in consequence of universal suffrage, the Jews would still everywhere remain a minority in need of protection, which alone would find adequate support in no national chamber. A new order of "protected Jews" would arise, as humiliating as that of the Middle Ages. We should no longer be the Schutzjuden and chamber-serfs of a king, but instead those of all the parties.
Fortunately the national-territorial autonomy is not yet law, nor will it become so very soon. Development, in particular, is at times so wilful as not to wish to take the road which straight-thinking party leaders prescribe for it. It sometimes makes a little detour and then often reappears in a wholly altered shape. This will probably be the case here also. The Social Democrats rightly emphasized at the Bruenn Party Congress that the autonomy they had resolved upon may be enacted only by a democratic parliament proceeding from universal suffrage. In framing the new electoral reform the Government has now gone a step further. In declaring that that the new electoral reform was to open a future to national autonomy, it has logically attempted to build the Parliament itself upon a national foundation; for if in the new Parliament the nations themselves are to settle their general accounts with one another in brotherly fashion, it is only right and fair that all the nations should be represented therein in accordance with their strength.
Accordingly a beginning was made with the apportionment of the mandates from national points of view. First of all, for Moravia, where Czechs and Germans dwell most intermingled with one another and the national struggle raged fiercely, national curiae were contemplated, for the Reichsrat as for the Diet elections,
2*
