Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 49 · 7 December 1906
14printed page
scan 12 of 20
Facsimile · scan 12 of 20
Scan of p. 14
English · AI translation, checked against the German

14 — "Die Welt" — No. 49

(continued from page 13)

…can conceal. And while even the Information Bureau in Jaffa sees itself compelled to declare immigration advisable at present only for capitalists, Messrs. Warburg, Nossig and others are developing, in speech and in writing, the view that Palestine already offers the best conditions for receiving the great stream of Jewish emigrants. Indeed, if in all this a thorough turning away from the whole previous policy, tactics and method of Zionism is not to be seen, then we may as well admit only one fundamental law for our movement: "Whatever pleases is permitted!" No hair-splitting dialectic will be able to persuade us that there are only nuances here, which leave matters of principle untouched.

This denial of old dogmas, this overthrow of all principles, means in any case a grave crisis in a movement that has lasted only 10 years, and this crisis could be salutary only if it were justified by a complete change in the external conditions of our policy. But what has changed in this respect in recent years? The political conditions? The Sultan has always been a warm friend of the Jews; nevertheless he has hitherto opposed a decisive resistance to our political aspirations, and we have no sign that the least thing has changed in his views on the subject. The whole political constellation for Turkey, internal and external, has moreover become rather more difficult than easier in recent years. Or has something changed in the economic conditions of the work in Palestine? The economic-political rivalry of the Great Powers in Turkey and its neighbouring countries is surely no result of recent years, but dates back for decades; and the nervous fear that everything might be bought away from under our noses was, if at all, just as well founded at the beginning of our movement as to-day, and will not be banished from the world by land purchases of a few millions either. Or have all the other conditions of development for a Zionist colonisation become so very different just in the most recent time that what still appeared so very precarious in 1904 promises a brilliant future to-day? Nothing whatever has changed in all this, and to-day, as years ago, the word of an expert holds good, which Prof. Warburg himself quoted approvingly: "Under these circumstances the idea of a foreign, non-Moslem colonisation must be described as a Utopia!"

The saddest thing about this whole overthrow of Zionist views is the misjudgment not only of all factors that lie within the range of combination, judgment and conception, but even of the most elementary arithmetical relations. The cry of distress of Kremenezky, the faithful Ekkehard of the N. F. ("Welt" No. 46), reveals in all its sharpness the hopelessness of approaching the solution of present economic tasks with the means that could be at our disposal within any foreseeable time. Only think: the fourth part of the N. F. is already tied up in lands which cannot be turned to account at present, and for the experimental station, about which there has been talk for years and about which no difference of opinion whatever exists, there has, it is true, been an agronomist employed for two years already at a salary of 5 000 Frs. — but no land has yet been bought! When this has been done and the station erected, the stock of the N. F., laboriously attained in five years, will have been spent to the extent of $^4/_5$, and the interest on the remainder will scarcely suffice to cover the most necessary current expenses. And withal the complaints of our "practical" Zionists will not fall silent, that the A. C. opposes passive resistance to the work in Palestine and that far too little has yet been done in this direction. To boundless and irresponsible project-mongering, such as was so aptly scourged by Achad Haam in the heyday of the Chibas Zion, door and gate are thrown open once more; and where this must lead, Kremenezky — unhappily only now — has shown with brutal plainness: to a National Fund crash!

In this financial state of affairs the understanding is really very simple for all who truly wish to have peace in the movement: let us confine ourselves to those works which are proportionate to our means, well compatible with the previous Zionist policy, and welcome also to every political Zionist. Agricultural, technical, meteorological and hygienic stations of observation, experiment and investigation, a teaching and model farm, an Information Bureau and a Statistical Office — these things would claim for ten years and longer all the means available and still to be raised, and could fully occupy all those who really wish to enter the service of this work in Palestine. And let us adjourn questions of principle, which under the present conditions are of a purely academic character, to the time when the tasks of a preparatory kind have been solved! Perhaps in the meantime the conditions for undertakings which go beyond the sphere of preparatory and informatory work will change thoroughly, and means for such things may then also be made available from other quarters. In the meantime an understanding on the differences in the Palestine question would in and of itself be a considerable relief of the present critical situation in Zionism. To serve this and to make sacrifices for it, all should be ready who still stand steadfastly gathered round the banner of the Basle Programme.

Dr. Karl Jeremias, Posen.


The Position of the National Fund

In connection with Mr. Kremenezky's article in No. 46 of "Die Welt" on the position and administration of the Jewish National Fund, we have received from our circle of readers a number of letters in which we are asked for closer information about the actual present situation of the National Fund. We therefore turned to the most competent quarter, the Zionist Central Bureau in Cologne, with the request that it give us an authentic account. Below we publish the information thereupon furnished us by the Central Bureau. These particulars, which show that Mr. Kremenezky evidently proceeds in his remarks from false premises and arrives at false conclusions, furnish the proof that the A.-K. has proceeded with thorough caution in the use and investment of the money of the N.-F., and that there is absolutely no ground whatever for apprehension that the N.-F. would be used in precipitate fashion for the purchase of lands, or that its rights of ownership in them are insecure.

The Central Bureau informs us as follows:

Tied up, i.e. expended, from the assets of the National Fund are:

For purchase of land in Palestine£ 7 500.—
For the equipment of the experimental station£ 1 200.—
Total£ 8 700.—

Granted, i.e. provided for as expenditure, are:

For various land purchases£ 7 750.—
By resolution of the Annual Conference:
For purchase of land for settling immigrant workmen£ 800.—
For purchase of land to be leased to the Kishineff orphans£ 2 450.—
For purchase of a site for the Bezalel£ 1 200.—
Total£ 12 200.—

No grants other than those named above exist.

It should, however, be emphasised that no obligation to purchase lands for the N.-F. exists apart from the grants made by the Annual Conference, and that in particular it is highly doubtful whether, of the sum of £ 7 750.— provided for various land purchases, more than about £ 3 000.— will ever be expended.

The experimental station, like the Bezalel, will not become a Zionist institution, but is to be founded as a company. Apart from the £ 1200.— already entered above and already paid out, no money whatever has been granted by the N.-F. for this purpose.

Thus, of the total assets of the Jewish National Fund, which on the 31st October of this year amounted to about £ 54.000.—, there have been expended for land purchases etc. £ 8.700.—, granted £ 12 200.— and