Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 49 · 7 December 1906
10printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 10 — "Die Welt" — No. 49.

(continued from page 9)

…voices to ignore completely. But it is well known that the Russian Government continually reckons with precisely this section of public opinion, and indeed lets itself be terrorised by it. When it was learned in government circles that the extension of Jewish rights had called forth a storm of discontent among the "truly Russian people," all the promises were simply revoked.

Thus wavering between "reform" and revocation, the Government, naturally by its own fault, finds it no easy matter on the one hand not to stir up the pogrom-thirsty pack, and on the other to present at least the semblance of good will to the discontented Jewish elements, irritated to the utmost and doubly dangerous before the elections — that is, to take up such a position on the Jewish question ut aliquid fieri videatur. Its latest confession of faith therefore sounds very tortuous and forced — towards the right and towards the left, if with such moderation, merely academic as it is, one can speak of a "left" at all.

In its organ "Rossija" it declares: The Government sees clearly that certain groups wish to influence the Government to the detriment of the Jews. These tendencies, it says, are called forth by exaggerated political passion, but the Government must keep in view the general good of the Empire and proceed very cautiously in the especially difficult Jewish question. After the dissolution of the Duma, which had called forth a great unrest and irritation, the Government had to turn its attention to the morbid phenomena of Russian life. Among other matters, special attention was given to the Jewish question, since the irritated temper of a section of the population numbering 5 millions of people could not, after all, be regarded as normal. The ordinances of the Government, however, must not be regarded as concessions in favour of revolutionary insolence, and must contain nothing harmful to the Russian people. From this standpoint the abolition of the Pale of Settlement before the meeting of the Duma, and the immediate grant of the right to own land, at a time when the mobilisation of the State land reserve is in fact going on, would be rash and premature. Before the convocation of the Duma the Government could only abolish the restrictions within the bounds of the Pale of Settlement. In this way, to be sure, the Government would gain no new adherents, and the Jews, who wish to get into their hands not only political rights but also political preponderance (!), would only feel themselves offended. On the other hand, again, those who see in the Jewish question a weapon of political passion will very sharply oppose these ordinances, and will even accuse the Government of treason. But since the Government has come to the conviction that a part of the population is with full right discontented with its situation, and sees the only way out of this situation in revolutionary violence, the Government sees itself obliged to adopt measures which might bring about another way out. A part of the Jews will, thanks to the new ordinances, obtain a great field of activity for its energy and enterprise, and will find in itself the strength, without regard to the striving for political supremacy, to appreciate the privileges granted to it before all others, and to let not only bomb-throwers and robbers come forth from its midst. For the State, however, this would mean a great benefit.

So far the "Rossija." The organ of the Cadets, the "Rjetsch," remarks as follows upon these manoeuvres of constitutional magnanimity, which exhaust themselves in announcements and revocations: "Our Constitution, according to statistical calculations now made, has cost the Jews dear: from October 1900 to July 1906 (that is, up to Bjelostok) pogroms were organised in 638 places; the number of families who suffered through the pogroms

reaches the figure of 37 075, which amounts to somewhat over 150 000 persons. 1000 killed, as many wounded, about 1500 orphans and 51 millions of material damage — thus have the Jews had to pay for the 'freedom bestowed.'"

In the background of this cynical game with the "reforms in the Jewish question," however, one sees the arrangement of a new loan. And with a guileless upward glance the money-seeking Government shows the civilised Europeans its great work: the "emancipation of the Jews."

The Jewish Community and the Zionists

A highly significant sign of the irresistibly advancing force of the Zionist idea was offered by the elections just held for the Board of the Vienna Jewish Community. Vienna was the city where, years ago, Zionists entered for the first time into the electoral struggle for the "conquest" of the Jewish communities. Even that first onset had shown that the Zionists, although their organisation was numerically not over-strong in proportion to the great community, might nevertheless count, far beyond their firmly organised ranks, upon strong sympathies among the soundest Jewish elements and upon actual support at the decisive moment. "For the sake of dear peace" the Vienna Zionists later did not exploit their strength, but, trusting that the Board would learn from the signs of the times and would amicably carry through a reform in head and members, contented themselves with being represented by one or two Zionist members of the Board. The Zionists made a mistake in this. All respect to the honourableness of the persons of the old Board; but in political life the opposition of two systems, nay, of two views of life, is not settled by compromises. And so the Vienna Board, once it sat quietly in its nest again, brought out the old, lazy jog-trot once more and governed away as in the best Liberal times, and unleashed the discontent of the national and democratic circles all the more, the more the hard times demanded an upright, energetic representation of Jewish interests. It is well known that the conduct of the Vienna Board in the scandalous Taussig affair, over whose negotiation of the Russian loan it spread the mantle of collegial indulgence among members of the Board, kindled the most vivid indignation wherever Jews live, and even among non-Jews. This act of the Board alone was enough to open the eyes of those Vienna Jews who hold to their honour as to how far their leaders still are from a recognition of their Jewish duties. Many local matters — such as the notorious franchise, which excludes the less well-to-do from taking part in the vote and which the Board would not give up, and the neglect of the care of the poor and the sick — were added to call forth a great ferment among the electorate. The Zionists went into battle again, and that with their whole energy. And this time they have succeeded in inflicting on the Board so painful a reverse that it almost amounts to a complete victory. Only consider that the President of the Jewish Community, Dr. Stern, after the wealthy had mustered every man and every penny, was able to snatch the majority by barely 50 votes, while two Zionists, just below the majority, came into the second ballot. The old Board has still, by the skin of its teeth, saved the greater part of the seats, but no longer its honour. For only in form is Dr. Stern (or rather his system) to-day the leader of Jewish Vienna. Jewish Vienna, and above all that part of it which has been artificially excluded from the vote by the power of the lords of money, belongs to the new men, to the new system.

American Jewish Committee

What not so very long ago even optimists had held to be impossible, or at least improbable, now stands before us as a fact: American Jewry has, to itself,