No. 50 — "Die Welt" — 11
Of late the need for serious present-day work in Russia itself has been ripening. The Russian movement for freedom set the Russian Zionists a difficult question, since it was hard for them to decide which party they ought to join. In this respect the Zionists were entirely thrown back upon themselves. The Russian movement harboured many dangers of assimilation. Under these conditions nothing remained for the Z.-B. but to take the lead in this question. The activity of the Z.-B. in this direction, which was furthered by the societies, aimed at nationalising the other political Jewish bodies, such as the League for Equal Rights, etc. It also proved possible to have five of the twelve Jewish deputies to the Duma elected from the ranks of the Zionists. Our further activity will be determined by the Conference. We propose the founding of an election fund. In the matter of the pogroms the Z.-B. displayed a lively activity, both in information and agitation and in the investigation of the pogroms, with which Mr. L. Motzkin was entrusted. The Z.-B. likewise initiated considerable collections of money on behalf of the victims of the pogroms. A sum of 1000 pounds sterling was granted by the Z.-B. for the founding of a whole series of information bureaus and other institutions, which were then also approved by the Cologne Conference.
II.
As regards the administrative activity proper of the Z.-B. in the course of the year under report, we may emphasise the following: Conferences of the members of the A. C. were frequently held in Vilna, and played an important part in the development of the organisation. The activity of the Z.-B. was, however, hampered by the dispersal of the district leaders and by the lack of agitators and of inspectors of the societies. It held an inquiry among the societies, to which 442 replies were received from the societies. This inquiry gave a fairly clear picture of the state of the party. The questionnaires likewise served to establish an exact list of the addresses of the Zionist societies. Also other Zionist work, such as the preparations for the Brussels Conference and for the Shekel days during the Hagbalah days, which were initiated by the inner A. C.
The cash turnover of the Z.-B. from 1 September 1905 to 1 November 1906 amounted to 54 243 R. 25 Kop. The year under report was one of the poorest in Shekel receipts. Up to 1 November of this year (O. S.), 14 519 R. 89 Kop. came in for Shekels, and after 1 XI. 1500 R. A further 512 R. 19 Kop. were received without designation. The total Shekel receipts may thus be reckoned at 17 000 R. This is greater than in the year of the VIIth Congress, but less than in the preceding years. The average Shekel receipts for 8 years amounted to over 33 000 R. (33 058.22), varying between 15 300 (VIIth year) and 62 013 R. 28 Kop. (VIth year). The National Fund moneys received by the Z.-B. this year were far more considerable than before; instead of the 3—5 thousand roubles of earlier years they amounted to 21 018 R. 86 Kop. Self-taxation sums came in to the amount of only 573 R. 94 K., and for shares of the J.-K.-B. and the A.-P.-B. 784 R. 35 K.
The Z.-B. prepared 150 000 Shekel receipts for the IXth year, of which 141 000 receipts had been sent out by 15 July of this year. Although we had no exact data on the use of the Shekels, we assume that the number does not exceed 100 000. Money came in for 35 000 Shekels. For the Xth Congress year the Z.-B. had 150 000 Shekel receipts printed. In order to facilitate and control those National Fund collections which are not brought about by way of the sale of stamps, 15 000 receipt blocks have been prepared. 1500 blocks have already been sent out.
The expenditure for this year amounted to 8016 R. 49 K. for the district outlays, the greater part of these sums falling to the districts of the South-West (in the districts of Dr. Sapir and Scheinkin), — which is a smaller amount in comparison with the VIIth year (10 264 R.) and with the VIIIth (14 415 R.). The expenditure on written agitation amounted to 4016 R. 13 K., which is an increase over the previous years. Besides this the Z.-B. expended a further 6000 roubles out of the special sums standing at its disposal. Thus the household of the Bureau cost 3525 R. 76 K., the postal expenses 1695 R. 36 K., etc. In sum — the expenditure exceeds the income by 6185 R., apart from the debt of 3000 R. to Cologne and a loan of 4203 R. The Z.-B. proposes to the Conference that means be found to cover this deficit and in general to furnish the centre with more ample means.
Lively debates followed upon the report of the Central Bureau. The first to speak was Mr. Grünbaum (Warsaw). He said, among other things: Our district, namely that of Poland, found itself in a peculiar situation. We actually had a district leader for only two months, since Mr. N. Sokolow, our district leader, has for some considerable time no longer lived in Russia. The threads of the organisation in Poland were thus wrested from our hands. The Bureau for the Organisation in Poland, on its constitution, found the conditions within the organisation in a chaotic state. And nowhere was the crisis in Zionism so visible as in Warsaw and in Lodz, that is, in the great cities of Poland. Formerly we had 9000 Shekel-payers there, now only 6000. In the provinces the crisis has left no traces. We had to go through a struggle with the Territorialists. Our activity was a many-sided one. The first circular to the societies that went out from our Bureau concerned the question of present-day work; the second (in the October days) formulated our national platform. The Bureau of the Zionist Organisation for Poland took no part in the elections for the first Duma, for the feeling of the progressive part of society was for the boycott of the Duma — and we were obliged to take account of this feeling. The recently held conference of the representatives of the Zionist societies of the Government of Pietrokow accepted the national-political platform. In this respect, therefore, our activity was successful. We could not, however, carry on sufficient agitation, because we lacked the means. For this very same reason, and on account of the difficult position of the organisation in Poland, we were unable to convene a conference of the Zionists of all Poland.
Bregman (Pinsk): In discussing the report of the Z.-B. I shall subject to criticism not the Z.-B. but the institution of the district leaders itself. I point out that some of our leading A. C. members are opponents of practical work in Palestine. The course of Zionist work is often hampered by this. I ask the A. C.: what has become of the resolution of the VIIth Congress that the two Russian members of the inner A. C. should remove to Berlin? We are told there is no money for it. But if there is no work, there will be no money either. They simply did not wish to carry out the resolution. The question now is — who was it that placed the obstacles in the way? There must be a control of the policy of the inner A. C. The control must be exercised in accordance with the resolution of the Congress. . . . We are now in a perilous position. The position of Zionism is an exceedingly difficult one. Still more difficult, and at the same time sadder, is the general situation in Russia. One must work for Zionism — but the Central Bureau in Vilna is merely a chancery, simply a bureau, which can indeed register but not create. The Conference must see to the abolition of the institution of the district leaders and found a new Z.-B., to be composed of men who could devote themselves wholly to the cause. In conclusion I should like to put a question to the Z.-B. concerning the article by Kremenetzky on the National Fund moneys which appeared in "Die Welt". What is its attitude to this tactless and disorganising pronouncement by a member of the greater A. C.?
Dreisenstock (Lodz): I do not believe that the replacement of the institution of the district leaders by the Z.-B. would be of considerable benefit. The most important thing, after all, is the necessary, truly capable men. The question now is where the cause of the crisis in our party lies. It is not the revolution, and not the pogroms. The reason lies in this, that the Zionist movement is still in many respects in the stage of moods and has not yet attained that of ideas. That is why the consciousness of aim is not yet strong enough; that is why the societies and the district leaders, too, are not equal to their task. A Zionist consciousness must be created — and that can be done only by means of a clear programme, a clear position towards the movement for liberation. We suffer from the overestimation of the territorial factor. All sides of the movement must be of equal importance.
Babkow (St. Petersburg): I would point out that our debates must proceed within certain limits. The Z.-B. has done everything that it could do with its means. Since we shall still have occasion to speak on the questions of present-day policy, I consider it inappropriate to raise this question here.
Mrs. Lichtenstein (Warsaw): The A. C. says it has no means, and that for that reason it was also unable to give the Palestine Commission the money due to it. But the A. C. ought to have applied to the organisation for money. The A. C. did not do so; consequently this question, like the resolution of the VIIth Congress mentioned by a previous speaker, has no value. Neither the Z.-B. nor the A. C. has established an information bureau for the emigrants in Palestine.
Kabarlitzki (Nikolajew) demands an explanation on the question of the mutual relations of the district leaders to one another. Is there harmony in their midst or not?
