No. 51 — "Die Welt" — 17
CORRESPONDENCE
(This column, for which the Editors bear no responsibility, is, as we have repeatedly remarked, open to letters from our readers and to the free exchange of opinion.)
Meran (Tyrol), 16th Dec. 1906.
Dear Sir,
I beg you to be so good as to grant the following lines admission to the open forum of Die Welt:
On the 29th of November a meeting organised by the newly founded Misrachi group took place at Berlin in Dräsel's Festival Halls, at which Dr. L. Franck of Altona delivered a finished address on the theme: "Law-Observant Judaism and Zionism." It was preceded by a lecture of Professor Dr. Berliner, which — as I, in my capacity as chairman and convener, expressly emphasised in my introductory words — was unofficial. This lecture first offered a sharp criticism — painful for all Zionists — of Herzl and of the so-called "crass, national" Zionism, in order in its second part to call upon all law-observant Jews to join especially from student circles, who at first, under the national banner, turned once more to the Jewish confession, but were then saved for Jewish life and religious practice. We know it ourselves from various occurrences, and have also heard it from others, how parents were led back to Jewish life by their Zionist children." . .
"The law-observant will, to be sure, keep watch that everything is put into effect according to the supreme principle, which will be set out more fully below; in this they will nevertheless trust the Nationalists, so long as these persist in their specific standpoint, since they may expect the following of them:
No Zionist will, as so often happens in other circles, send his child to the church for baptism after its birth!
Work by pupils of the upper classes of the Bezalel
the Misrachi and, through it, the Zionist movement! In the course of the very lively discussion I was reproached more than once with having permitted such a criticism of Herzl at a Zionist meeting at all. To this I reply that I held the breach which the celebrated scholar made with his enthusiastic appeal to join the Misrachi to be far more important than the criticism of Herzl's religious views, which in any case can easily be refuted from another quarter. In my justification I let the venerable champion of Berlin's law-observant Jewry, who, moreover, declared himself willing to take full responsibility for his lecture, speak for himself, by quoting some passages from the lecture word for word: "Yea, they that sow in tears shall reap in joy! But sow we must, and not fold our hands in our lap! Prayer accomplishes but the half, say our Sages; yet it strengthens us for the deed which we mean to undertake in trust in God, namely for the Zionist movement, which so many have entered, to guide it into the right paths for the development of a religious-national movement. May we find one another in our common love of Zion, and not let ourselves be deterred by the perception of how many we shall meet therein who, as atheists, as deniers of the Torah and its precepts, hide beneath the dark shadow of "national Jew." Let us rather look at the young men, no Zionist will vote that Jewish divine service be Christianised by the introduction of the organ or by German prayers!
No Zionist will vote that the Hebrew language be banished from the Jewish house of God!
No Zionist will vote that Sunday be instituted as the day of rest and holy day in place of the Sabbath!
Thus the law-observant Jews may already expect the Zionists, as opponents of assimilation, to help them in the struggle against the so-called Reform!"
"I emphasise 'a common activity,' for the Misrachi group will affiliate itself with the organisation as a whole, and this on the ground of the following considerations:
"As its supreme, guiding principle the Congress has declared: Zionism undertakes nothing that is contrary to the religious law of Judaism." (See Schachtel: "Resolutions . . . ." p. 13.)
Further: "For entry into the Zionist organisation a twofold condition is required, which every law-observant Jew can accept without misgiving. First, the payment of a shekel into the common treasury . . . . . The second condition is that he who enters the organisation of Zionism stand on the ground of the Basle Programme. To this, too, the law-observant Jew can declare himself ready. With the striving for the creation