The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
13printed page
scan 11 of 54

Zionism, Anti-Semitism, Etc.

I S Don Quixote dead? Evidently not, for one sees ever and anon knights of a sorry countenance undertaking the repetition of the famous fight against windmills, formidable enemies of their own imagination. I cannot help saying it, since the polemics against Zionism strike me in this fashion. On the one side there are men to whom Judaism is a mere pretence, whose ceremonies and traditions they have discarded long ago, and who suddenly feel called upon to defend against Zionism that which they have hitherto condemned and spurned. Others develop a new ethno-psychology of their own and evolve new principles of nationalism, patriotism and tutti-frutti of a novel pattern to which no one else could subscribe for a minute; but every stick is good enough to beat a dog with. Happily Zionism is not a dog. It may turn out to be the old lion of Judah, lying so long asleep that people trod upon him with impunity. How many asses thought it wise to kick the dead lion, I leave the reader to count, if he has patience enough for such mathematical problems.

But to return to our Don Quixotes. There are others who also find new views in the old Bible, and show an unwonted and startling love for verses of the Prophets torn from their context and interpreted in a manner of which they would be ashamed to apply to any modern writer, who could then safely institute proceedings of defamation and libel against them. A belief is suddenly engendered in biblical statements, not one of which would be allowed to interfere with the predilections and even frivolous pastimes of those who now so loudly proclaim the supposed or fancied contradiction between this sentence of the Prophet and the aims of Zionism. The old spirit of the Ghetto is more responsible for much that is being said and written against Zionism than any will own, but it is none the less true. At the bottom of the opposition lies the fear of being misinterpreted by our neighbors, the fear of jeopardizing a liberty that exists practically only in name for the majority of the Jews throughout the world, the fear of endangering the position which the modern "Schutzjuden" enjoy. This has to answer for much of the bitterness of the polemics between Zionists and anti-Zionists.

And is not the desire of sharpening one's wits at one's neighbor's expense and of maintaining just the contrary of what the other thinks and believes, part and parcel of the Ghetto spirit and of the Pilpul, which trains the mind to find out and to invent contradictions, even when there is none in existence? But in one point does the anti-Zionist differ from the state of the mind of the old Student (Bachur) of the tradition, in as much as there is no longer the desire to harmonize, to show unity in diversity. On the contrary, he dwells complacently or bitterly on the supposed differences, all, mind, the result of his own imagination. Windmills, and nothing else!

I have been asked to write something on Zionism for the new review devoted to the propagation of this principle, and I find that in spite of all that has been written from our side hitherto, in spite of what has been explained viva voce by Zionists, we are in the same position, for the Jews in general are face to face with anti-Semitism. Whatever the Jews write remains for home consumption; their antagonists do not even take the trouble to read and thus to be converted, or at any rate to be shaken in their prejudice and to be weakened in their animosity. Seas of ink have been poured out to defend us from the foul accusations heaped up against us, and with what result? We must confess with none whatsoever. True, it is almost futile to try and convince an antagonist who does not wish to be convinced, who will coolly ignore all that can be advanced against him, and who will repeat the old, stale and over and again refuted statements, as if they were quite new arguments never heard of before and never examined and pulverized before. And yet we ought at least not lay ourselves open to the same charge, that we refuse to listen to the refutation or baselessness of the cause as our anti-Semitic opponents regularly do. The least we ask is patient hearing and careful weighing of the pros and cons and not to be met with prejudice and pusillanimous fear, the most abject remnant of the old Ghetto. I know it is not a spirit of wickedness or malice, no hatred or venomous enmity which closes the eyes and ears of our opponents, as is the case with the anti-Semites. Nothing further from us, even to mention the two in one breath. The anti-Zionists are, we credit