Federation calling a convention, the purpose for sending a delegate is to take note of what has not been done by the Federation. After the delegate returns with his incomplete, often disgruntled and pessimistic report, the members indulge in grumbling, are much disgusted with the Federation, and deliver themselves of more fiery denunciatory speeches. The society then drags along, waiting for some sensation to break the monotony of its existence.
Needless to state, such a society is fundamentally weak and its propagation of the cause is ineffective.
The following is the right way :
Let the group of ardent and sensible Zionists who would propagate Zionism, send to THE MACCABÆAN or to the Federation of American Zionists, for a constitution defining its position in the hierarchy of societies, the duties of officers, committees, etc. After the receipt of the constitution and detailed instruction, let these pioneers canvass their district to discover the sympathizers of the movement for national rehabilitation. Quietly let a meeting be called and an organization affected, composed of men thoroughly inspired with the Jewish spirit; then let a committee be appointed with stated duties and let stated meeting be arranged for. When the completed organization is in good working order, let a mass meeting be called to expound to the larger public, which is as yet unfamiliar with Zionism, what the movement aims to accomplish, and let the periodic mass meeting supplement the stated monthly or bi-monthly meetings of the society.
And, above all, let not this society hold aloof from interests that apparently are not Zionistic; but let it assist every Jewish movement that aims for culture, knowledge of Jewish history and Jewish life. Let it not hold aloof from movements that give expression to some particular phase of Jewish life, say in literature, art or science. Let it not refuse to assist the persecuted because the methods in vogue do not aim completely to solve the difficulty. But under all circumstances, be broad and liberal-minded, with the purpose clearly in view to realize that composite Jewish life, sometimes called the Jewish national life, of which the term Zionism is the collective expression.
This right way we commend to all Zionists.
"Whoso loveth correction, loveth wisdom." The methods of Zionist organization necessitate reproof; will our Zionist brethren profit by it?
[From a letter to the Editor.]
The Highest Development
Nᴼ movement has arisen in my time in Jewry so conducive to the intellectual development of Israel. Zionism, even if it fails, will have been a success. It will have brought the younger generation in contact with a living religious impulse, and I doubt if your Reform Synagogue has succeeded in doing that. I had the impression when I was in America that the one vital Judaism was the racial brotherhood, expressed not by Temples, but .by clubs. But the racial brotherhood can find a higher expression than clubs.
To all of us the Zionist movement is valuable as forcing us "to stop and think," as Tolstoi recommends; it forces us to define our concept of the best development of our race and religion. I regard the American alternative of a denationalized Judaism as more honest and possible than the muddle of a non-Zionist "orthodoxy." But then that alternative is not carried to its logical extreme of an apostolic religion. There is still this parochial intermarrying; in short, there is a latent Zionism.
No Jew in his senses can deny he would rather be born in his own country than in a country in which he has to prove painfully that he is a native. Considering how particularised the Jew is, it is astonishing he does not see that other people also like to close in their ranks against the stranger. i
ISRAEL ZANGWILL.
William McKinley
WITH our countrymen — the American people — we mourn the death of an excellent man in the person of our late Executive. The blow struck by the misguided and utterly wretched assassin has been condemned, in some cases with frenzy and delirious advice as to his future treatment, by the entire American press and pulpit. In Mr. McKinley the nation has lost a truly pious man, one who represented with dignity and honor those virtues that are closely associated in our mind with the sterling American character. To Jews, representatives of family virtue in times past and still we believe, in advance of other nations, noteworthy in this bereavement of the nation, are the fine eulogies we hear from our English brothers, who, in synagogue and press, have expressed their sympathy with the American people. That America, “ the home of the free,”