The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 2 · November 1901
67printed page
scan 11 of 48

meaning, is the religion of the Jews.” The more detailed content of this religion is a different question.

VI.

Judaism is not a universal religion. Rightly understood it is a national religion. There would be no Judaism without Jews.

VII.

But Judaism contains certain universal elements, certain absolute and eternal truths. It holds that certain of its metaphysical propositions which have found expression and acceptance among the Jewish people, and certain ethical principles of the same, are destined to become the common property of the whole world, and it hopes that they will actually be the common property of all peoples, some day.

VIII.

But Judaism does not limit itself to these universal elements, which, in a measure, at least, are already appropriated by other peoples. Taken in this sense, it requires additional manifestations: a certain characteristic ritual, certain established national days of consecration, certain defined national symbols and ceremonies. The choice of a Seventh day of the week as a sanctified day of rest and spiritual upliftment, the Jewish Festivals, the Jewish Calendar, and the like, are only nationally Jewish, and have no universal qualities, and it would be folly to claim for such as these any universal recognition.

IX.

Were we to separate from Judaism all that is nationally Jewish, the traditional Sabbath and Festivals, the common elements that are still observed in our ritual, and were we to limit ourselves to that which is called the eternal, the lasting, the universal in Judaism, then indeed we would have a Church or a religious community which would rest on the basis of Theism and would teach and require the highest ethics. Then we would have a universal religion, like that which is desired by those who dispute the proposition, that Judaism is a racial community, and who would place in its stead as a fundamental principle, that Judaism is a religion and nothing more than a religion.

X.

But accepting such reasoning, are we not forced to draw the conclusions therefrom? There are

already a very large number of Jews racially bound to us, who have not joined any Jewish congregation and would not be willing to join any; or who have affiliated themselves with liberal religious organizations whose members are not exclusively of Jewish stock. If one listens to them, one will hear them say, that for those Jews with whom the theory of the existence of a racial bond of union with the rest of Jews is emphatically repudiated, and a racial distinction between Jews and Aryan nationalities is denied; and also for those Jews among whom the national sentiment has entirely disappeared,— for these there is not the slightest reason for still maintaining the barrier between Jewish and non-Jewish theists, and we may, and we should, permit these barriers to fall, and even assist in their complete destruction.

XI.

Judaism in its isolation, and as a national church, stands upon much more reasonable and sounder foundations than it would if it were to expand and become a so-called world religion. In the Jewish national religion, natural and inevitable community with the Jewish stock is the one all-embracing and uniting bond within which, however, there can be the broadest freedom of thought and research for the individual and for the united church, the widest room for free and full development. Within a national church there need be no dogmatic obstinacy. In the ancient Greek national religion there was no stiff and strictly formulated dogmas. In the old Germanic religion, there was no “Credo” and no Catechism. If these ancient national religions had not been displaced by the Christian world religion and its accompanying dogmas, advancing culture and the spread of knowledge would have worked here as a liberator as well, and would have excluded errors and incongruities that adhere to them to day, and the old religions would also have attained the clear heights.

XII

Non-Jewish religious organizations, which are entirely free from dogmatic constraint, cannot avoid being influenced by the geographic and historic conditions of the people among whom they live, so far as the construction of their ritual and their other forms are concerned. A religious organization dwelling, for instance, in the far North, would use for ritual purposes not the palm, but the fir tree; and in a country with the vegetation of a warmer zone, the contrary would