ism produced a distinct party in Judaism. They appeared both in the province of theory and in actual practice—theoretically, in the new science of Judaism formulated in the European languages; in the reform endeavors, by which the outward garb of the Jewish religion is to be changed. This reform policy seems to many, even to some of its advocates, to be a long stride forward on the road to assimilation. They are mistaken. As soon as self-renunciation has reached the point where those who practice it no longer feel an inner connection with the inheritance of their fathers, but seek, rather, to break away from it by thorough amalgamation with the alien community, these persons no longer feel a need to raise their ancestral inheritance to any desired perfection. On the other hand, they are more inclined to let things remain as they are until they disappear noiselessly of themselves. Up to this point, however, they imitate the acts of their fathers, whenever the necessity arises, with a kind of artificial self-renunciation, with indifference, as if they were not active agents, but as if the spirit of their fathers had mastered them, and were operating in the same way as in early times.
Somewhere Geiger gives expression to the opinion that he who now writes Hebrew no longer feels an inner connection with what he is writing; he is transported to an entirely different world of thought, to the world of the Talmud and the Rabbis, into whose attitude of mind he must force himself. Geiger's opinion is justified in regard to the scholars of the Occident. Their Hebrew style shows that the language of their race no longer forms a part of their own being. But the writers of the east-European countries and of the Holy Land, who regard the language of their fathers as still a part of themselves, feel that exactly when they are writing Hebrew, they must draw upon the depths of their own nature. Accordingly, they make an effort to remodel and perfect the language, so that it may become a convenient instrument for conveying thought, as it once was with their fathers.
When we see Geiger and his successors devoting time and strength to the perfecting (as they think) of their ancestral religious inheritance, discontented in one place with what gives them satisfaction in another, we are convinced that here lies the source of their Jewish individuality, a much shrunken individuality, to be sure, but not quite extinct. We are convinced that their real inner desire, whether they admit it to them-
selves and others or not, is "to express their own individuality through the same sort of deeds which the one imitated performed in accordance with his own individuality."
* * *
It is evident, then, that our people need fear nothing from assimilation, even in the future. What they must fear is dismemberment. As the kind of activity in which our people develop their national peculiarity in each country depends upon the spiritual force prevalent there and stimulating competitive imitation, the fear is justified lest this activity should scatter in various directions according to the spirit animating the different nations. So that in the course of time, the Jewish people might no longer be one people, but separate tribes, as they were in the beginning.
In fact, reasons for this dread are provided by actual experience. For instance: the east-European Jews received their culture from the German Jews. Hence the object of their self-renunciation, the center of their imitation, was not the alien spiritual power of the country in which they lived, but their fellow-Jews in another land. Accordingly their imitation was absolute. They paid no regard to differences of country and of conditions. They tried to be true Germans in all details. But after a time enlightenment spread in a certain degree to the east-European Jews, and the new spirit found its way to their consciousness. Immediately their attitude to the German Jews changed from self-renunciation to competition, and they varied their model according to the spiritual power of their own country.
European culture has been almost completely adopted by the Russian Jews, and, in spite of all internal and external obstacles, it makes rapid progress toward fuller adoption. The impulse was originally given by the school of Mendelssohn, the effects of which have been apparent since the “thirties” of the last century. It is not a long time ago that whoever possessed European learning was dubbed “Berliner,” and at this day, in Poland, those who wear the European costume are called “Germans.” The Hebrew writers of the first and, in part, of the second generation saw in the German Jews, whom, it is true, they knew only from the literature on the science of Judaism, the embodiment of their ideal, “within his habitation, a Jew; without, a man” (according to the words of Jehuda Leb Gordon). And before the German Jews, they felt themselves bound to practise self-renunciation. An