The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 3 · December 1901
137printed page
scan 33 of 102

in what may be termed local history. Henry Necarsulmer gives an account of the Early Jewish Settlement at Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Henry Berkowitz contributes a History of the Earliest German-Jewish Congregation in America, the Rodeph Shalom of Philadelphia; and J. D. Eisenstein tells the story of the first Russian-Jewish Congregation, the Beth Hamedrash Hagodol of New York, which has had an interesting history. In addition there are studies by Leon Huehner, Max J. Kohler, Herbert Friedenwald and a Plea for an American Jewish Historical Exhibition, by Joseph Jacobs, which was preliminary to the action of the Society on the question of holding of an exhibition.

Deborah. By J. M. Ludlow. Fleming H. Revell Company, New York.

This tale of the Maccabæan period is peculiarly fitting for Chanuka time. It tells in a vivacious style the history of the first few years of the Jewish revolt. The romance of it is thoroughly enjoyable, and written by one who is evidently a master of historical description. An immense amount of archæological knowledge is displayed by Dr. Ludlow who has made a scholarly study of the period. Books of this kind are essential. They present in vivid colors a time which neither

A DAUGHTER OF JERUSALEM.

the philosophy of the thinker, nor the researches of the scholar, can make real to the popular mind.

Deborah is a fine type of Jewish womanhood, sacrificing herself unquestioning, to the demands of the fatherland. The character of her brother, Glaucus, so called, typifies the degradation of the Jews of the time. The defeat of Apollonius is described with the pen of one who is familiar with military tactics and who knows intimately the topography of the country. It is a book that touches the national sentiment.

Zur Geschichte der Juden in Maehren und Oesterr.-Schlesien. Von Christian Ritter d'Elvert. Bruenn. Pp. iii—269.

This monograph forms the fourth part of the venerable author's contributions to the History of Austrian Law and Jurisprudence. It is a thorough piece of work and an authoritative narrative of Jewish history in the lands included in its scope. An introduction deals carefully with the literature of the subject. With each title, a succinct commentary on the work is connected, this being in itself an arduous and well-nigh impossible task for a nonogenarian.

The present work opens with an historical and statistical sketch of the Jews. Short accounts of conditions just after the Diaspora are succeeded by reviews of the persecutions suffered in the states of Continental Europe.

Passing from the general to the particular, the historical aspect of Jewish condition in Austria-Hungary is then considered. The history of the Jews in Moravia, the ground properly covered by this study, is then discussed with a detail that leaves nothing to be desired. Then follows a similar review of events which transpired in Bohemia, in Austrian-Silesia, etc.

There is so much to praise in this study which is indeed the most valuable guide to the history of the Jews in Austria-Hungary, that the few unfavorable elements hardly deserve mention. In its present state, however, the volume is absolutely useless to the student as a work of reference because, like the majority of the scientific works in Germany and Austria which have not yet felt the Anglo-Saxon influence of summarization and of the codifying of facts, there is no index of things or of persons. Although the work is by no means to be viewed as valueless still such it must be for the “runner who reads,” for it is not to be expected that the busy student will have the time to go through the entire work — not even provided with a table of contents — and so separate what is for him the wheat from the chaff.

These are minor blemishes, it is true, but they nevertheless render the present work inaccessible to those who have not the time to go with any degree of care from cover to cover.

Jewish conditions in Moravia are discussed with reference to the rebellion and the Thirty Years' War. The Counter-reformation in Moravia in its effect on the position of the Jews is alluded to and the revolution of political relations in respect to the clerical influence on education,