The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 5 · May 1902
251printed page
scan 11 of 54

only to edit this particular collection of records, and his work should be gauged by these purposes alone. Yet one must regret also that the severe form of the Selden Society’s publications has so completely eliminated the personality of the editor in the body of the work, even as concerns annotations, except in the matter of deciphering, translating, and occasionally identifying persons or places! This may be more “scientific”, and prevents obtrusion of possibly incorrect theories as to the importance and character of particular determinations, but splendid opportunities for philosophizing and explaining are thus foregone, not likely to be afforded soon again, and the value of the work to the general reader and even to most students is thus diminished. I must confess that, in spite of possible sacrifices of “dignity,” the form and method of Mr. Joseph Jacobs’ work have much to recommend them over the system here pursued. But these criticisms are of trifling import compared with the gratification and pleasure the perusal of this valuable work affords, and any student or reader may be quite certain that Mr. Rigg’s book will be constantly quoted and referred to as an indispensable contribution to English Jewish history in general.

Mr. Rigg exhibits his independence of authority in declining to characterize the Jew in early England as a sort of "serf;" his familiarity and recognition of the obverse side of the picture must have convinced him of the incorrectness of such a view. Thus he breaks away from Pollock and Maitland's authority, who said [I, p. 455] “we call him a serf. We have no direct authority for so doing, for we have seen no text in which he is called *servous*; but Bracton has gone very near this word when he said that what the Jew acquires, he acquires for the king.” It is a great advance over this and similar views to recognize, as does Mr. Rigg (p. XXXVII), that “in a large sense this status was one of perpetual wardship. The King through his justices gave them his tutelage, and there was no ultimate limit but his will to the number and nature of the restrictions and exactions which he might impose upon them,” while, on the other hand, “they escaped villeinage”, “were exempted from tolls and customs, including the wine duty, and from all jurisdiction, except that of the King himself or his castellanes.” It has been customary to regard Jewish legal status from the point of view of later times, when disabilities continued or had been increased, while earlier privileges and immunities had been cut off by the efforts of a

more recently developed commercial rivalry. The fact is, as this volume so well illustrates, that the exceptional position of the Jew in early Europe had its advantages, as well as disadvantages, over that of other residents. As wards of the King, they were subject to unlimited restrictions and exactions on the King's part, it is true, but the other side of the ledger is that they received charters making them free from the burdens of the feudal system, enjoyed a monopoly of "usury" (interest-taking), were not subjected to various customs and general taxes, enjoyed a partial judicial autonomy, were free from Church exactions and had their own ecclesiastical laws in large measure administered among Jewish residents in the civil courts of law as the "law of the land." The large mass of records here gathered together permits the student to investigate this anomalous condition, as he is unable to do in any other country. Moreover, historical conditions in England were more favorable than elsewhere to the free development of both the advantages and disadvantages the Jews thus enjoyed, by reason of the enormous influence of the Crown during the period under consideration. Principles of law, resulting from this "wardship" theory—for, as well as against, the Jew—are thus applied in fact in some of these adjudged cases, which the continental student has been bound to consider the extremes of a correct theory, not likely to be actually realized in practice. This circumstance, in its favorable bearing upon Jewish rights, is well phrased by Mr. Rigg as follows: "The effect was to place the Jew at a great advantage over the Christian both for attack and defence. The intention was to use the Jewry as a reservoir equally open to receive, and closed to retain, the surplus wealth of the surrounding population, so that the Crown might never lack a fund, on which to draw in the hour of need."

Mr. Rigg's Introduction and text indicate how the privileges and immunities came to be curtailed in England, and the disabilities and exactions increased, culminating in the decree of expulsion in 1290, and then becoming even more rigorous than on the continent in general. The very circumstance of the realization of great privileges and immunities at an early day, produced in large measure this reaction. Commercial rivalry, jealousy of immunities and privileges, hatred entertained by indigent debtor classes for their creditors, and religious animosity increased by the Crusades, made the Jews more and more unpopular with the masses, while on the other