The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
102printed page
scan 44 of 56

thoughts the pulpits, that have the ear of the press, never speak, that great mass, though not yet active, still stands to-day even as the Jew fleeing or led a slave from Palestine, stood nineteen hundred years ago, pledged to the old oath of allegiance. "If I forget thee, oh Jerusalem, let my right hand forget its cunning."

IN THE SIGHT OF ALL MEN

THIS issue of the MACCABÆAN contains a verbatim report of the statement and evidence given by Dr. Herzl before the Royal Commission on Alien Immigration, sitting in London. Dr. Herzl was invited by the Commission to state his views on the Jewish question, and every careful reader of his clear and definite words, and the sometimes brilliant cross-examination, will find once for all that if Zionism has its sentimental side it is still based upon a foundation of keen and pointed logic that it is grounded on the clear and precise understanding of Jewish affairs in detail and in general.

By appearing before the Commission Dr.Herzl has practically stood before the bar of the world. We do not for a moment say that every man would be convinced at once by what he has said, nor that we find every one of his observations flawless; but we do contend that no such masterly exposition of Jewish affairs has been presented by any Jew to an authoritative body, and that, perhaps excepting Moses Montefiore, no representative Jew has so frankly and boldly stood up, casting aside all other interests, as a representative of the Jews. It will be but natural that hundreds of institutions whose policy and methods are scored in single phrases, will, in the privacy of committee and council rooms, debate and contend against Dr. Herzl's observations.

But this is exactly what we want. Therefore, we are more than glad that Dr. Herzl appeared before the Royal Commission and provided us with so much food for reflection.

DIFFERENCES AND DISTINCTIONS

Nᴼ Jew can read this record of Dr. Herzl's evidence without being cut to the quick by one thought. That is, that while a Royal Commission, representing the British Empire,

thought sufficiently highly of the man, his methods and his ideals, to send for him, to extend to him a hearty welcome and to greet him as he deserves to be greeted, as one of the foremost statesmen of his time, the so-called representative Jews, especially those who have the purses, and who administer the exchequers of our great institutions, had neither the courtesy nor the tact heretofore to greet him, or to offer to receive him and his colleagues. There could be no greater disparity than between the reception accorded Zionism by the representatives of the British Government and that shown it by the administrators of the Jewish Colonization Association, who we can well understand, under the circumstances, wish to get off the question on a side issue.

In this, however, they will not succeed, and they will do well to remember, as should other Jewish organizations that have governing power, that the world, to whose opinion they must bow, does not ignore the fact, and will in the long run take notice of it, that they refuse either to help or to listen to a policy for the futile reason, so it strikes the average man, that it is not of their invention.

AN APOLOGY

THE Israelit, of Maintz, the famous organ of German orthodoxy which was the vehicle of so many slanderous statements on the movement and, together with the Jewish Chronicle, published the slanderous attack of the Jewish Colonial Trust in the early part of the year, has now apologized to the Zionist movement.

Herr Oscar Lehman, editor of the Israelit, recently had an interview with Herr D. Wolfssohn, chairman of the Trust, Dr. M. Bodenheimer, president of the German Federation of Zionists, and after explanations signed a document expressing his conviction that the accusations against the management of the Trust were without foundation, and that he withdrew them, expressing deep regret. Herr Lehman has further undertaken not to accept any more contributions of the author of the incriminating article, nor anything against the movement from the writer of an article entitled "Zionism and Missions to Jews."

This, in effect, means the dismissal of Herr Willy Bambus, who, we believe, was the author of those attacks. Our belief is based