The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 5 · November 1902
275printed page
scan 47 of 54

RE-DISPERSION

THE latest panacea for Jewish trouble isthat of re-dispersing the dispersed.With that we can have nothing to do despiteits attractiveness. Convinced though we arethat the congestion of areas is bad, especiallyfor the health of the inhabitants of a district, it is equally clear that human beingscannot be repenned as though they were somany cattle; and that if they were willing toyield themselves to such treatment, the lastcondition would be absolutely worse than thefirst. There is something quite natural butnot always reasonable in the herding together of immigrants, especially when to thestrangeness of country is added the strangeness of speech; and it is still more naturaland much more reasonable that any mass ofpeople shall ignore directions given fromabove.

What those who really wish to take a hand at solving local problems should remember is that they must first prove to the Jewish people that they are of them and with them before they can expect the masses to treat them otherwise than with the contempt from which they suffer at the present time.

Serious troubles, such as those with which the Jewish people are beset, cannot be settled off-hand. Nothing is accomplished by even the most remarkable orator. Such problems are for serious thinkers, men capable of dealing with the issues exactly in the same way as the politicians or any other people deal with affairs. It is this air of reality which is lacking in everything we read or hear of in connection with the settlement of the Jewish problems in the great cities of the United States.

THE SPECIAL EDITION

ZIONISM does not exist for the special edition of the newspaper, nor will it flourish thereby. Still less are we living at the pace of the electric cable. Of all the news that has been published during the last month we can only deny one item: The Jewish Colonial Trust has not declared a dividend, but will do so next year. There is no cause for disappointment in this; if the cash is

ready it will still take many months to organize the cashing of coupons out in all parts of the world. We would ask everyone to remember that in Zionism he or she is but one in a quarter of a million, and the pace must be adjusted to the possibilities of so intricate a network as the dispersal of the Jews.

Of all the other news, the ipsi dixit of statesmen and reporters, of land purchases and universities to be erected, we can only say we cannot confirm these items. Something is guesswork, something is truth in all these matters, "but the proportions vary greatly. One thing we have demonstrated, that is that we feel strong enough to tell the truth. Either in victory or defeat it will be the official announcement which will tell the whole truth. On the other hand it must be understood that a movement engaged in diplomatic negotiations cannot take stock of every guess and prophecy, for it is the business of diplomacy to say nothing until the fact is accomplished. We are the more anxious to impress this upon our readers, for we would have it understood that the truth of Zionism will not be proven by victory as little as it could be impaired by defeat, and it is conviction, not the acceptance of triumph, that must unite Israel.

Books Received

"Tzar" (Hebrew), by Zevi Hirsch Robinson (New York).

"Anti-Semitism and Zionism." Correspondence reprinted from the Jewish Chronicle (London). 58 pp.

"The Spirit of the Ghetto," by Hutchins Hapgood (New York: Funk & Wagnalls).

"Der Yiddische National Fund," an explanatory pamphlet in Yiddish, by Ben Adam. (London: Maarive.)

"The Reader" Magazine, November. New York.

"The North American Review," November.

"The American Jewish Year Book." (Jewish Publication Society.)

"Zionist Correspondence." (London.)

"Jeudische National Presse." (Berlin.)