The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 5 · May 1903
278printed page
scan 37 of 62

It is not, perhaps, generally known that Dr. Gottheil retained to his last days a great liking for Talmudic exegesis. He was wont to stop Jewish peddlers, who passed his house, and discuss Talmudic questions with them. And he often expressed his admiration for the deep Jewish learning and true stoicism concealed under the rags of these unfortunate people.

An incident in connection with this habit of his occurred about two years ago, when he was residing in one of the suburbs of New York. As he was taking his afternoon stroll he noticed a Jewish peddler offering the Mincha prayer. When the peddler had finished with his devotions he entered into a Talmudic discussion with him. Finding him to be a man of unusual intelligence, he asked him to join him at his evening meal. The peddler declined. Dr. Gottheil being a goluach (one who is shaven) he, the peddler, could not, under the Talmudic law, break bread with him. “ For the first time in my life, since I entered upon my career as a reformer,” said Dr. Gottheil in relating this incident to the writer, “ I felt a pang that I had helped to bring about a state of affairs which forbade this brother of mine to eat with me at the same table.”

Nor was this the only time that this Jew of Jews expressed his regret at a condition of affairs which divides the Jewish people into two camps. He did not take the initiative in eliminating from the ritual historic prayers and sacred ceremonials. His congregation, composed of Jews who were among the leaders in the social and financial life of the American metropolis, was determined that its form of worship should be thoroughly in keeping with modernity. He felt it was better to retain these men and women within the fold than to let them slip all the bonds of Judaism. "Believe me," he said in an earnest and almost pathetic tone, when we were discussing the question, "my congregation reformed me more than I reformed it."

It was this faithful devotion to the faith of his fathers that made him such a stanch Zionist. He saw that American Judaism was drifting aimlessly and without a rudder, and he grasped at the idea of anchoring it to its ancient land and sacred history. It was an inspiring sight to see this patriarch, feeble and bent with age and cares, leaning on the arm of his son, coming late o' nights to Zionist gatherings, and beaming with enthusiasm when a speaker made a telling point. The Zionist conventions were all held in the heat of summer, when younger and stronger men sought the seashore and mountains. But he insisted upon attending every one, and took the utmost interest in the proceedings.

He not only helped the cause with his words and with his pen, but with his purse. The early pamphlets published by the Federation of American Zionists, when that organization was in its infancy, were published at his expense. He never missed an opportunity of preaching the Zionist ideal, and even went to the extent of attempting to enlist the sympathy of Andrew Carnegie for the cause.

"I could not sleep last night," he told me one day when I called on him. "And where do you think my thoughts were? In Jaffa. When we obtain the charter what are we to do without a harbor? How shall we ship our products, and where shall we craft that will convey the fruits of Jewish industry to foreign lands find a safe anchorage?" Such were his thoughts on his sleepless nights.