Dr. Gustav Gottheil—A Tribute
By L. LIPSKY.
The Federation of American Zionists, in common with the Jews of this Continent, mourns the death of Gustav Gottheil. He was the patriarch of the movement in America. With the energetic and virile old man, Dr. Bernard Felsenthal, Dr. Gottheil gave the stamp of venerableness to the movement, which is as old as the memory of Bar Kochba, and which depends for its success to-day on the youthful enthusiasm of its workers. He stood for the visible link which bound the movement to the greatness of the past. The relation of these two men, in their mellow old age, helped to give a public firmness to the Jewish national movement of to-day, a movement which in the short time of five years has made such rapid progress, that the support of old age was perhaps necessary.
Dr. Gottheil made manifest, in his enthusiastic concern for Zionism, and his lofty conception of its ideals, that there was nothing contradictory to his religious view point in Jewish nationalism. His sagacity and his deep-seated Jewish consciousness, which never forsook him, led him ever to hope for the triumphant progress of the Jewish people from the gloom of dispersion to the bloom of a brilliant national existence. He held his religious opinions dear, but he recognized the futility of expecting that religion to flourish while his people were the dust which every European broom, at its pleasure, could scatter to the winds. Dr. Gottheil stood as a protest against that hasty and unwise declaration of his colleagues in the reform movement, which presumed to assert the fragmentary self-complacency of the Jewish people in the lands where they were permitted to breathe with ease.
The loss of Dr. Gottheil to the Jewish national endeavor cannot be measured. The influence of patriotism is never to be estimated by rule. But his value would have been as nothing if he had not by his enthusiasm and devotion fired the spirits of hundreds of the young men of our people to emulate his patriotism, his enthusiasm, and to hold his high opinion of the destiny of his people.
When that venerable figure, with the splendid head, typical of the ruggedness of his character, the persistence of his patriotism, the strength of his purpose, and the tenacity of his race, stood before a Jewish audience, of the working force of our people, old, orthodox, foreign, begrimed, but hopeful, and he spoke, even in his last day, tremulously, perhaps, while his eyes peered into that shadow land of whose mysteries we know little or nothing, for "Zion and its hills," for the "land of our sires," and for "our noble heritage," which he would not have the Jewish people forget in dispersion, will any one say that the winds bore away his utterance of his soul and there was mere silence? The Jewish nationalist will not believe it. Rather would he believe that to every one who heard his voice there came that consciousness of nationality, which in days to come would flower and give motive to endeavor and endeavor to realize the dream which the old, time-worn, rugged, yet hopeful old patriarch so often dreamt and for the realization of which he so earnestly strove in the last years of his useful life.