The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
60scan
of 86

and at such places as may be deemed expedient by the Executive Council.” That is all ofthat section.

"(f) The Board of Deputies shall consider at its meetings reports and recommendations of territorial groups of the district and report on territorial work at the annual Convention; and it shall give consideration to such requirements of the Executive Council as shall affect the organizations territorially." That is, the Board of Deputies shall report to the annual Convention whatever it has done, whatever the groups have done during the year. And it shall receive and give consideration to such recommendations as the Executive Council or the Convention may provide.

"(g) Each territorial group or district shall be required to report to the Board of Deputies on the status of its constituency, and to present such statistical information as may be called for from time to time." There is a change there, substituting "territorial groups" for "deputies."

“(h) The various territorial groups shall be defined by the Committee on Organization.”

At the suggestion of the President the word "additional" was added to Sub-section Ia, so that it shall read: "The Executive Council shall consist of the President, two Vice-presidents, Treasurer, Secretary and eight additional members," etc.

A member moved to amend this section by changing the number to be elected from eight to fifteen, the purpose of the amendment being that with a small council it is often found impossible to get together an effective working majority; with a larger number more business would be effected.

President Gottheil: On the other hand it is very hard to work with a large committee. The committees that work best are committees of one. What is needed is to have men on the committee who will work and upon whom we can depend. We need quality rather than quantity.

The Secretary wished to re-commit to the committee the report on the following ground: The committee has not apparently thought out the results of its new clauses. According to the statement made by Mr. Lipsky, clause e, old clause c, and clause f would naturally fall to the ground. Because the Board of Deputies as originally provided for would be a large body, therefore there was a

natural necessity for convening meeting of so large a body. But under the new system, where each deputy represents but one group, the total number of deputies could not be in the ensuing year more than, say, ten.

Mr. Morrison suggested that in view of thefact that there seems to be a demand on thepart of some delegates to the Convention fora larger Executive Committee, that the number be made ten instead of eight or fifteen.

The debate was taken up by Messrs. Lipsky, Borofsky and Fishman, the question atissue being the need of the meetings of theBoard of Deputies.

On motion it was ordered that the consideration of the report of the committee be taken up and acted upon seriatim.

taken up and acted upon seriatim.Article V, Section 1. The chairman of thecommittee stated that there was no changein this section.

Mr. Zolotkoff asked what was the meaning, of the practical working out, of this section. Did the Council expect to reorganize existing bodies into smaller groups, or do away with existing bodies? He quoted the order Knights of Zion. They had 84 or 86 organizations covering a large territory in the West. These represent an enormous amount of organizing labor and were working pretty well. If they were to go by Article 5 as proposed here, what were they to do in order to conform to the requirements of this amendment?

The President: The allotting of territory will, of course, remain with the Executive Council; the Executive Council will, of course, take into consideration existing organizations. It always will do that, and the organizations that belong to this Federation must have sufficient loyalty and faith in its officers and Executive Council to feel that they will do what is right and proper. It would be suicidal on our part to oppose any such organizations, but we should rather work together along the lines laid out by such organizations. And if the organization represented by Mr. Zolotkoff have fealty toward the Federation they will be perfectly sure that there will be no difficulty.

After a verbal amendment, the clause as amended, was carried.

Mr. Lipsky moved the adoption of Sub-section Ia as reported by the committee, the only change being to elect eight members