tionize a movement, and without these things a convention is a failure. The Pittsburg Convention not only did some of these things, but it loudly favored that stern discipline which heretofore has been lacking in all Jewish affairs. It is very far from the purpose of Zionism to crush the individual; but some part of each individual must be merged into the ranks of the party, else the party is powerless, and, in a crisis, useless. The Convention could not and would not, by resolution, kill the individual crank. It could not put out of existence that spirit of rebellion, which is characteristic of some Jewish elements, but it demonstrated plainly enough, that it had learned a lesson of modern political life, which expressed, simply amounts to this: That he is not a real partisan or follower of an idea, who cannot yield his own personality to the goodwill and needs of the party to which he belongs. It is a paradox that this attitude is adopted by those who clamor loudest for freedom, but it is one of the paradoxes in which the contradictory elements are equally true. The mental attitude of our people favors the freelance, but freelances, however, are only good for a skirmish. The Jews have to fight a great battle in which only disciplined force can win. The Convention understood this, and acted upon that principle.
JEWISH POLITICS
A T the moment of writing, every Jew in the United States is moved by the action of President Roosevelt in forwarding the petition of the Bnai Brith to the Czar, to ask him a number of questions. Was it wise to present that petition? Was it wise to press its forwarding? Was it wise to forward it? Will it affect, or can it affect, the position of the Jews in America? Will is affect, by its acceptance or rejection, the position of the Jews in Russia?
We do not propose to answer these questions, because the answers are in process of formation, even before our views can see the light of print. Sufficient if we do not admit that if a thing does no good it does no harm. It must do one or the other, and futile efforts bring bigger punishments than mere waste of time.
Our point is that these questions suggest, and should suggest, to the mind of every Jew the thought: We should have a Jewish policy, which, in its turn, should be the expres-
sion and wish of the Jewish people. There is nothing to prevent any group of Jews memorializing anyone, and no one petition has any greater sanction than any other one; since, however well-meaning the petitioners are—and of this there can in this case be no question—the petitioners, however wealthy and however generally representative, are not responsible to the Jewish people, neither here nor elsewhere.
Excepting the Zionist programme, no policy has been put before the people, who must bear the brunt of it, in one way or another, and no means have yet been found, by our socially representative men, of discovering what the Jewish people really wish, and what risks, in certain conditions, they are willing to take.
No one even of the particular petitioners can say of a surety how those to be affected, the Russian Jews, view such a step; whether they willingly accept the chance of possible martyrdom as against the possible risk of improved conditions, which may follow the presentation of this petition.
This thing is not new; on the contrary, it was ever so. The oligarchy may be unintentional, but it exists in Jewry, and a hundred years of its rule does not convince us that irresponsible statesmanship has done much to further the permanent interests of the Jewish people.
Clearly, a Jewish policy must proceed from a Jewish government, and government is built upon a state; but even while that does not exist there are forms to hand by which the real wishes of the Jewish people can be made known. The Zionists have shown that a moral force abides in a Jewish Congress, that its writ runs far and is duly honored and respected. And even while a Zionist Congress represents that active element in the people which entitles it to call itself the nation, yet the Zionist is neither so narrow nor so bigoted as to ignore the fact that a Pan-Jewish Congress, a world gathering of all shades of Jewish thought, would outshine it in glory and outvie it in power. And it is this which we need; and it is this that every Jew should strive for, for as long as any general policy has not the expressed sanction of the people, through their representatives, so long will every policy prove abortive, doing little good and always armed with the possibility of doing much injury.