The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 3 · September 1903
169printed page
scan 24 of 58

water of Christianity to neutralize successfully that in the Jewish character at which Christians have always taken umbrage, to smooth over with a fair measure of real results the points of difference between the Jew and the Christian. The lives of all the converted Jews since the dawn of Christianity, are proof positive of the correctness of these assertions. Take, for example, the German poet Heine. To the Jews he was a Christian, to the Christians a Jew.

Can we call Zionism the policy of surrender? Are we justified in demanding an heroic fortitude of a mere handful of Jews against overwhelming numbers of Christians, when the pages of history can only evidence Thermopylæ as a similar example of steadfast devotion? I divest myself utterly of the fabric of romance, of the trappings of sentiment, when I quote the satirical couplet which has ever been recited in those cases where discretion triumphed over valor:

"He who fights and runs away, Lives to fight another day."

Opponents of Zionism* admit that, with the Jewish problem, there is bound up another problem, the "real problem of the twentieth century [which] is the backwardness of the nations, not the forwardness of the Jews."† Of course, the limitations of my subject prevent my emphasizing all that it noble, dignified and sublime in that movement, which is blindly called a "policy of surrender" in some quarters.

After all, it must needs be Isaiah or one with a strong soul, suffused with Isaiah's ideals,who can teach men their lessons. Isaiah inveighed against capital in his writings. He sidedwith the "landless and homeless" because he recognized the futility of building an imposingsuperstructure of idealism on a foundation of sand, on economic realities which could notbear the burden thrust upon them.

Dr. Theodor Herzl has made no mistake in his “Judenstaat,” for the latest “Altneuland” shows that sound economic principles have been considered in an effort to realize seriously the Jewish state. At present this nationality exists only on paper, but in a manner that differs radically from all other projects of earlier times, whether these were influenced by Utopianism, Platonism, Fourierism, Owenism, Transcendentalism or not. It is true that discussion of economic, practical topics in advance of their realization inevitably fritters away into theory, but it is hardly too much to say that such a treatment as this results in familiarizing the masses of the population of the new state with problems of government, of every-day life which can then be solved easily when the crux is hit.

Indeed, the student of the history of the later Israelites, of the period of the kingdoms of Judah and Israel, is entirely at home in economic discussion. Problems of wealth, of the relations of labor and capital, are met there at every turn. The twenty-fifth chapter of Leviticus, the Jubilee legislation may be used by the followers of Dr. Herzl with this important advantage: history affords a striking commentary on these Biblical words and the mistakes of ancestors need not be repeated by their descendants.

To affect to despise the partisans of Zionism, to look upon the Zionist movement as a delusion and vain attempt, is to shut one's eyes deliberately to the facts of contemporary history and firmly to avow one's belief in the providential character of the progress of the world, of the march of humanity. The Jew is the Azazel of modern times, and simply because he is a thinking person he strives to deflect the impending cataclysm from himself by removing himself from its course. The scapegoat of ancient days was set out in the wilderness and left to drift for himself, the thinking being of our own times wishes to remove from the jealous neighbor to a locality where he can work out his own destiny according to his own lights.

Let me follow out this thought to its logical conclusion. Jews are growing weary of the reproach: You are Luftmenschen, men without a country! From the viewpoint of the economist, it is deleterious on the people among whom the Jews reside for the former to cast their own omissions and commissions on the latter. Economic effects must issue from economic causes within the same limits: there can no more be an economic effect of a springing or shifting character, less even an adventitious growth, than houses can be built of the very material that is used in the construction of other edifices. The Jews, then, seek to escape the storm

* "A Quarterly Reviewer," Aspects of the Jewish Question, New York, 1902.

† Ibid., p. viii.