The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
265printed page
scan 66 of 80

The Maccabæan

EDITORIAL PAGES

J. DE HAAS, EDITOR

THE SIXTH CONGRESS

THE great Congress has been—it was, and it conquered. Like a concealed jet suddenly shooting a stream of flame into the air, so this Congress has rushed blindingly along, and not a few of its phenomena have the characteristics of terrestrial convulsions. It is simply sublime egoism or stupidity—sometimes one and the same thing—that can answer all the phenomena of this Congress by so many simple affirmations or negations.

Never did Zionism need at once more careful handling and directing, and therefore it was necessary for us to note first the salient facts. There were, as far as American Zionists are concerned, six salient results of this Congress—two of which are specifically American. These facts are (I) the East African Protectorate plan, (2) the letter from M. von Plehve, (3) the increase of the delegation constituency, (4) the determination to use the funds of the National Fund at once for the purchase of land in Palestine, (5) the founding of a branch of the Trust in New York in accordance with the wishes of the Pittsburg Convention, (6) the decision rendering necessary the convening of an American Convention which shall decide how many federations shall exist in the United States.

POLITICS

THE Congress could do no more nor less than appoint a commission to investigate the East African offer made by the British Government. Frankly, the “night asylum” is no more provided for in the Zionist program than Kishineff belongs to the order of civilized happenings. The immediate advantage of the East African offer is that by it ten thousand light-o’-wits are answered; the English Government recognizes the national existence of the Jews with the Zionists as the negotiating element. The fact will save reams of debate and puts us on a differ-

ent footing in all the courts of Europe. The British document is a mighty weapon, and there are those who know how to wield it. For the rest, our face is set toward Zion. The inquiry expedition will be formed up, and when it reports we shall take action. By this, we do not dismiss the question; far be that from our mind, but it is the first simple and direct policy in a difficult issue.

RUSSIA

THE Von Plehve letter deserves a welcome. It is so frank in its desire to be rid of the Jews that we can forgive the minister his imaginary humanitarian solicitude. In another sense, of course, the letter is humiliating. Great Russia wishes to be rid of the Jews. Bah! We knew it, and the fact might as well see the light of day. It will save so many people the trouble of speculating further on eleemosynary plans for the amelioration of Jewish conditions in Russia. Pharaoh may provide the straw for the bricks; it would be a strange kindness on the part of the taskmaster, but we have to read the other side, too, of this letter. With one hand it promises to aid even Zionistic diplomacy—undreamt-of achievement—with the other to suppress the movement if some Zionists do some things for which the general body of the Zionists cannot be held responsible. And if the Russian movement is suppressed, the answer must be the growth of the movement in America and nowhere else, for in no other country is there a sufficiently large Jewish population to replace the masses in Russia who would thus be prevented from taking their part in our work.

HOME AFFAIRS

WE come thus suddenly to affairs nearer home. We are convinced that only American Jewry can permanently help the Zionist cause, because of its freedom and position; we are equally convinced that within a few months the American movement can rise to great heights, winning men, influence, masses. On the other hand, however, the American movement can, before the end of this year, have burnt out like a bad rocket, of which no one ever seeks the stick as a memento.

The creation of what has been called “a