birth, and which office no other government, no matter how friendly, can undertake to do for him. This may be possible from Palestine; practically impossible from East Africa. Word it whichever way you will, East Africa simply means a colony, Palestine a national state. Palestine is the only land acknowledged by the people of the earth as the Jews' land. Rehabilitation there on a national footing is possible if persevered in, while everywhere else, colony or no colony, the Jew will ever remain the wandering Jew. The first re-establishment of a Jewish national government must be on Jewish soil, even if the territory so occupied is no larger than the Quirinal at Rome. Thereafter you may safely colonize elsewhere; but until then, if Zionism deviates from its rightful course and stretches forth its hands after strange gods, the injury done will be irreparable, and once more the effort to emancipate Judea will be a dream of the past. We need a leader great enough to lead our brethren back to the land of our fathers. Whether he is among us now or will appear a thousand years hence time alone will tell.
Rev. Dr. S. N. Deinard
Shall we take up a "Night Rev. Dr. S. N. Refuge" in British East AfDeinard rica, or shall it be only Zion, and at no time anything else but Zion? For the truly patriotic Jew, who loves his people, takes pride in their history, and is solicitous about their future, the answer must be a "Night Refuge" in East Africa as long as the road to Zion is not yet cleared of all obstructions. With an autonomous Jewish scttlement in East Africa as a vantage-ground we may strive for the ultimate goal all the more vigorously and successfully. It will not be the first time that Israel shall have returned to the land of his fathers after a sojourn in Egypt, Africa.
Those whose battle cry is "Zion or nothing!" forget that our first concern must be the restoration or resuscitation of the people, and then the restoration of the country; the "soul before the soil," to use a Zangwillian phrase. Give us an "Israel" and we shall then have an "Erez Israel."
Those who see in the Zionist movement a philanthropic scheme only, a means of preventing future Kishineff horrors, ought surely to welcome the solution of a legally se-
cured home under the suzerainty of a greatpower, no matter where that home be. Thosewho clamor for "Cultur" first and foremost, ought to know that a revival of theJewish spirit in life and literature, the cultivation of the Hebrew tongue, Jewish poetry,and Jewish science can be made possible onlywhen the Jews, or a large proportion of them,are removed from their foreign milien fromforeign influence, and, in a home of theirown, are surrounded by a purely Jewish atmosphere. In foreign lands Jewish life andJewish literature are hot-house plants, artificial products. And the religious enthusiastmust not forget that what is characteristically Jewish in Judaism is not so much its Palestinianism as its nationalism; institutionsbound up with the life of the Jews as a separate nation. Reform Judaism finds itself inits present plight only because of its excisionfrom Judaism of all its national elements, sothat the revival of the nation and then therestoration of the country, is a solution thatwill satisfy all aspirations.
Mr. Geo. Tunkle After a diligent and careful examination of the question, I have arrived at the conclusion that East Africa offers no solution to our troubles; that East Africa is not Zionism, and that true Zionism, therefore, cannot consistently, and with reason, entertain the proposition—a proposition which, in my opinion, is leading away from, instead of to, the goal of our nation’s hope, all the wise arguments of “profitable preparation, salutary probation,” to the contrary notwithstanding. I am almost tempted to say, Decline the tempting morsel and dismiss it from your mind as quickly as you can diplomatically do. I am almost tempted to say, Zion or nothing, though I am never in favor of hasty action.
East Africa! Uganda! Do not past hapless experiences suffice to convince us of the implausibility of, and the danger involved in, the scheme? The risk involved is too great, and the success too uncertain, too improbable, to justify an attempt at colonization in any place other than Palestine, and contiguous country.
I have not, permit me to add, hastily and without due consideration come to this conclusion. Profound respect for the opinions