The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 5 · November 1903
303printed page
scan 26 of 56

lions. The problem is vast and the means adopted to grapple with it should be correspondingly comprehensive. A small concession, 2,000 or 3,000 square miles, would offer no prospect of coping with the problem. A territory of not less than 50,000 square miles, which is about the size of the State of New York, is indispensable; 100,000 square miles would be better yet. As British East Africa is over 600,000 square miles in extent, this would not be an unreasonable demand. Besides it should be understood that while the proposed state is to be predominantly Jewish it would not imitate the narrow and proscriptive policies of the lands of its oppressors, but would welcome deserving settlers of other creed and kin, and that all men, without distinction, should enjoy within its borders the blessings of liberty and equal rights. Undertaken with zeal and pushed with energy, we might have the privilege of beholding Uganda speedily develop into a populous and prosperous country. That its growth, under modern conditions, could be very rapid we may infer from the example of Oklahoma, which in fourteen years has developed from an uninhabited wilderness into a mighty civilized and prosperous community of over half a million souls. Let us hope that our Jewish brethren will take up this task with the energy which they ever display in any cause in which their sympathies are truly enlisted, and that in the heart of Africa there will yet arise a great and flourishing Jewish state, a source of untold blessing to Israel and Israel's ideals, and of material advantage and benefit to the mighty and generous empire which made it possible.

An Interview with Dr. Herzl

Herr Rubin Brainin, the well-known Hebrew journalist, gives the following account of an interview he recently had with the Zionist leader:

Dr. Herzl said: "I desire to settle in no country but Palestine, even if the East African proposal turns out a success. . . . I have directed by my will that whenever I am summoned from the scene of my labors here, my remains are to be buried in the land of our fathers. . . . When I visited Russia some weeks ago I was already in possession of the British proposals. That, however, did not cause me to abate anything from our

original programme in regard to Palestine,and now I shall try to extract somethingtangible from the promises of good-will thathave been given. Never were our hopesbrighter than at the present for the attainment of our ultimate goal. To Africa Ishould not go; but it would have beenclearly impossible to have waived aside the`,offer of the British Government with a mereword. Such a perfunctory refusal would beto put a slight upon a Power that seeks ourwelfare. We must feel deeply grateful to theBritish Government in that, by its offer, ithas given recognition to our just claims toexist as a people under autonomous conditions. . . . The fact that a great Powerhas done this must rightly inspire us withrenewed hope that our desires in regard toour fatherland, and our peculiar fitness as an“old-new” people, standing on the topmostrungs of the ladder of development, to bringlife and industry and order there again, maybe recognized by the civilized world. . . .

"I find myself," continued Dr. Herzl, aftera moment's thoughtful silence, "I find myself somewhat in the position of the ass ofthe story that standing between two bundles of fodder, was at a loss to knowwhere to begin. Now if the ass hadbeen possessed of common sense and apair of hands, he would have grasped theone bundle and would have made a mealof the other. . . . Africa lies before uson the one hand; on the other there is thepossibility of Palestine. Of the one bundle,Africa, it is proposed to eat; the other weshall hold and put by awhile. . . . Youask me whether I am still a Zionist. Howcan you doubt it even for a moment? Howcan you lose confidence? If you are inclinedto doubt that it is for our ancient soil I stillyearn, that my one aim is Zion—have a littlemore patience and you will see that I havenot deceived the Zionists. In your ranks Ihave fought and with you I shall conquer. .. . But how could I possibly reject theBritish proposals without giving them the utmost consideration? Had I the right to doso in face of the fact that tens of thousandsof our brethren are seeking a refuge and ahome? Great Britain is desirous of giving agift of incalculable value to Israel—could Ihave passed the gift by without consulting thepeople? And if we had done so, what would