may be, the Chautauqua was organized, the school seeking the people. It wants the “masses” to eat of the whole loaf of Jewish knowledge; but it believes that the half loaf, or even a good slice is better than starvation— until the appetite has been properly stimulated. It has accordingly introduced Jewish study into many a home and many a community where little or nothing had been done theretofore, and the circle of its influence slowly but surely widens. It has widened as far as England, where the work is being duplicated. There has been no immediate stampede of the “masses” to it or to Jewish study anywhere. It never expected this, and nobody but a “critic” would castigate it for this. Every thinking person must see how gradual the development of such work must be. There are vast handicaps to which the pessimistic “critics” shut their eyes. But nevertheless the results have been gratifying. The courses of the Society, covering a large part of Jewish History and Literature, in Bible Study, in Fiction, and in Hebrew, for old and young, prepared by able men and women, speak for themselves and need no apology. As much or as little may be done as the time or inclination of the student may allow. Simple the courses may be, though there is provision in them also for more profound work. It would be as logical to call “superficial” the a, b, c taught to the child as to call these courses superficial—elementary, if you like, but not superficial; essential, not superficial.
As to its Summer Assembly, the "critic" to the contrary notwithstanding, it may justly claim to be the only Jewish forum for the whole Jewish people that American Jewry offers. A three weeks' work is necessarily limited, but there is always a plan and system in its work, as those who have followed it know; very little of disconnected, ephemeral effort has been tolerated; but it has been recognized that the three weeks' work can be only suggestive, a stimulus to further work, and this has been the aim. And for many who have attended these Assemblies, and who are not "indifferent sojourners," the writer can speak from experience that the Assembly has been the means of rousing their long dormant Jewish consciousness (almost it was unconsciousness).
The reference to Dr. Berkowitz, the head of the movement, as if he were the ringmas-
ter of a circus, is a contemptible bit of smart writing unworthy of further notice, as it was of publication.
Nor is the Assembly “abandoning education in a real sense and hitching its wagon to the glowing star of Jewish philanthropy.” A part of the time, always a subordinate part, has been given to those charity problems overwhelmingly great, which the Jewish people must solve. Their solution is a matter of concern and interest to a people’s assembly. Some comfort may be drawn from the phrase “abandonigs education in a real sense,” for, if the Society is “abandoning” education, it must once have had that purpose, something which the rest of the logical article seemed to deny. Let the critic take comfort. The Assembly is not “abandoning” education, though in one of its departments, as a place of popular conference, it is bound to take note of living questions, whether of philanthropy or anything else, upon which the Jewish people should be informed.
It may be mentioned in passing that the preface to the philanthropic work this year was a scholarly address by Dr. K. Kohler on "Jewish Philanthropy," historically considered. Jewish philanthropy is a part of Jewish life, which the critic insists is the end of Jewish education. He fails to note that the Chautauqua insists on the same thing.
In the second article, in the September MACCABÆAN, we are told that the writer does not think that the readers of the journal are interested enough to read a detailed account of the doings of the Assembly. It seems a pity that the writer should ex cathedra do all the thinking for the readers both as to what the news is and as to what the comment on it should be. Comment should be confined to the editorial page, not injected into what purports to be a news article. Why not state the facts, not garble them, and let the readers judge, or leave it all out?
Then we are told that the Assembly is only the "representative of the so-called leaders of the Jewish people, who come together a few weeks each year to discuss matters of more or less import," and later we are told that a certain meeting "was not as good as had been anticipated, owing to the freedom given to persons taking the floor." There is here some inconsistency, for the complaint is first that the Assembly is only of the leaders, and then