The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 5 · November 1903
310printed page
scan 33 of 56

ed past performances. Men of sincere purpose have been stared out of countenance byrecords compiled by overzealous partisans,and exaggeration has been made an essentialto the success of any movement which asksfor public support.

The paper read by the writer at Pittsburg was an endeavor to help prick the bubbles of inflationed values which have been puffed into the air by every Jewish organization in this country.

I admit the work done by the Jewish Chautauqua, and will take Mr. Hassler's valuation of it, minus all his adjectives. If the gentleman wants to consider a Hebrew class of twelve persons, meeting for a few weeks amid the excitements of a summer resort, of importance enough to warrant its seclusion in an inventory of the Chautauqua's great accomplishments, I am willing to let him do so. I do not consider it any more important than the starting of a Cheder in any small town by a melamed who receives fifty cents per week from each pupil.

I am not of the opinion that Dr. Kohler's paper on Jewish Charity, or Dr. Hirsch's lectures on the Fundamentals of Judaism, excellent in themselves, are of any educational value. I do not admit that the Jewish Chautauqua is a popular movement, or that it attempts to reach the masses of our people, for Mr. Hassler has no conception of who the Jewish people are, nor has the Chautauqua at any time tried to reach the Jewish people. In its reports its references are for the most part to the Summer Assembly, and it fails to give any satisfactory report on the work of its circles, which could be made a popular branch of its work if the leaders really appreciated the scope of the work before them.

It is needless to give a detailed reply to Mr. Hassler's rhetorical defense. I need not define what is meant by "superficial" and dilletante education. Genuine education does not resort to advertising schemes for its continuance, does not introduce the obscure and complex that stun but never enlighten its pupils. One would call that superficial which holds its eye to the register, looking for numbers, devotes itself to any topic which is uppermost in the public mind, and has not laid even the foundation for a healthy growth. One does not speak of our Council of Jewish Women, our Z. B. T. Fraternity, our Benai Berith lodges as educational institutions.

How hollow the assumption of the Jewish Chautauqua are may be gleaned from its advertisement of the English Ramsgate meeting as a product of its own exceedingly great activity. The fact is, both of these organizations are class organizations, catering to a select circle of people who are interested in Jewish matters with more or less definiteness.

I refer Mr. Hassler's concern for the readers of THE MACCABEAN to its editor. If Mr. Hassler will take note of some of our best journals he will see that the very same method attempted in The Record of the World's Progress is used by the Outlook, the Independent, the Review of Reviews, and by many weekly editions of our best newspapers. The space accorded the Jewish Chautauqua was commensurate with its value to our readers.

A good way to rid the world of pretension and cant is by ridicule; and if ridicule will bring the Jewish Chautauqua to see its errors and make an attempt to correct them, that method should be used whenever the occasion requires it.

LOUIS LIPSKY.