The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 6 · December 1903
364printed page
scan 33 of 63

superior to those under which they live in America or any other country. Far be it from him to belittle the perfect liberty and excellent government which they enjoy on this side the Atlantic, but they could not be blind to the fact that the economic conditions prevailing in western countries militated against the preservation and dissemination of their religious ideals and racial traditions. He instanced the difficulty encountered by Jewish young men who had to observe two days of rest out of seven if they were to be loyal to Judaism, and of the thousand and one other disadvantages under which they labored in striving to live true to their faith. All these economic difficulties would disappear in East Africa, for there they would live under Jewish laws and under a Jewish government. In the West the Jews form but a small minority of the population, and had to conform to the conditions created by a majority of another faith, conditions which, as he had shown, rendered the observance of Jewish teachings often very difficult. In East Africa the great mass of the population of their colony would be co-religionists, and the conditions for there developing the higher form of Jewish life would be immeasurably more favorable. Mr. de Sola in continuation said that for the first time they were now called upon to do practical work, and to show what they were capable of accomplishing when given a free hand. He had sufficient faith in the ability of Dr. Herzl and his associates to believe that they would succeed in anything they undertook in East Africa, or anywhere else, and that their success there would, far from injuring their prospects in regard to Palestine, open the eyes of the Sultan to the immense gain it would be to his empire to permit the establishment of a similar colony in the Holy Land. Mr. de Sola proceeded to reply to the various objections that had been raised, and with telling effect rolled up argument after argument in support of the action of the Congress, concluding with a vigorous and stirring appeal for support for the movement, the effect of which was made tangible by the inpouring of quite a large number of contributions toward the shekel fund before the meeting dispersed.

Mr. Moses Shapiro, one of the vice-presidents of the Federation, followed in a fluent

speech in Yiddish, in which he strongly supported Mr. de Sola's arguments.

After the collection for the shekel fund had been proceeded with by a band of Daughters of Zion the first resolution of the evening was introduced by Rev. Mendola de Sola in an eloquent and rousing speech burning with words of royalty, and at the conclusion of which the audience sprang to their feet and sang "God Save the King." The resolution was as follows:

"That this meeting of Canadian Zionists, both as British subjects and as Jews, expresses its deep appreciation and gratitude to His Majesty's Government for its generous offer in reference to the proposal to establish a Jewish colony in East Africa, and that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to the Imperial Government through the proper official channel."

The Rev. Herman Abramovitz seconded the resolution in an able and telling speech.

The second resolution was moved by Mr. M. Markus in a lucid address and was as follows:

"That this meeting of Canadian Zionists declares that it approves of the resolution of the Sixth Zionist Congress to appoint a commission to investigate and report upon the suitability of British East Africa for the establishment of a Jewish autonomous colony, and further, that if the report of the commission is favorable this meeting would approve of the British East African scheme purely as a means of relief for these Jews whose political and economic condition calls for immediate action."

The second resolution was supported in an eloquent and effective speech by Mr. J. S. Leo, secretary of the Federation, and president of the Montreal Zionist Society, who advanced powerful arguments in favor of the East African proposition, and whose words were received with frequent demonstrations of approval by the audience.

As this resolution brought up the main question, a general expression of opinion was invited, and a number of pithy and telling speeches were delivered, among the speakers being Mr. Asher Pierce, of Winnipeg, Manitoba, who argued strongly in support of the motion. The only speaker who dissented was Mr. I. I. Rubinowitz, of Vancouver, British Columbia, who favored the Canadian North-