The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 5 · May 1904
231printed page
scan 29 of 48

"religious literature" of the Jew. And since the rabbi still is the teacher of Judaism, an acquaintance with the literature of Judaism is necessary. But what is Judaism to the American Reform rabbi? Ah, here is the Sphinx that has already driven many a young rabbi to despair. And in their despair they left the pulpit, took up the study of law, of medicine, of what-not, or went into business. It was not lack of ability, or ignorance, or infidelity to the cause that forced them to desertion. On the contrary, their misfortune was—too much knowledge, logic, and honesty. They asked themselves again and again what this newly-coined phrase, "American Judaism," really meant, what peculiarity there was about this new religion that made its adherents keep separate and aloof from all other occidental and civilized religious organizations. In their perplexity they sought counsel from the older and wiser men, and in reply they heard words, words— long sonorous phrases, high-sounding words of Greek and Latin extraction, torrents of eloquence from the Titans of the Jewish pulpit, but in all these torrents of words the young, eager minds still missed logic and common sense.

What is American Judaism? It is certainly not rabbinism or legalism; it recognizes no authority in the Shulhan Arukh, and it dispenses with the tallith and tephillin, and the double set of pans and kettles. Does it recognize the Pentateuch as its final authority? No, bless you; it is not Sadducism or Karaism. And then, what young American rabbi is not familiar with the teachings of Wellhausen and Kuenen, Robertson, Smith and Cheyne, and with the results of modern Assyriology, the Delitzsch Babel-Bible equation. (I venture to say, that all the young rabbis who listened to Dr. Kohler's refutation of Delitzch's Babale-Bible argu-

ments are still more convinced by Delitzsch than by Kohler).

Whence, then, the authority vested in the Pentateuch? To the credit of Dr. S. M. Wise's consistency be it said that to the last he fought the ideas of the Higher Critics, and insisted on the Mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch, and on its being therefore authoritative for modern Judaism. But his own disciples have preferred to listen to the syren notes of the modern school.

Does their Judaism then subscribe to the cardinal and most characteristic doctrines of Jewish theology as formulated, say, by a Maimonides? Not a bit of it! The Law of Moses was not given to Moses on Sinai; we look forward to no Messiah, and the idea of resurrection is an old Parsee superstition.

It is thus easy to see what American Judaism is not. But what is it? And thereupon the answer comes: "It is Ethical Monotheism." A noble religion, indeed! But in what respect does it differ from the ethical monotheism of the Universalists, Unitarians and all other pure Deists? Is it simply the prejudice that the Jew has inherited against the name of Jesus? But this prejudice, too, is being rapidly overcome, and the young rabbis are now mentioning Moses and Jesus in the same breath without giving offense to anybody. What, then, is our ethical monotheism's distinguishing mark?

For this, too, an answer is still ready. Though there are others who are teaching the identical truths that constitute our religion, so the answer runs, we Jews are the providentially appointed missionaries to the nations of the world. Ours is not to question Providence's will as manifested in our history; ours is not to shirk the task, but rather to stand firm at our post.