The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 5 · May 1904
246printed page
scan 44 of 48

the House of Commons Jewish members who were recognized as champions of their people. Now, as far as we learn, only one leading man, Sir Charles Dilke, remained true to the Liberal creed and forcibly opposed this measure of oppression.

That the most able representative of labor in the British House of Commons should have taken a similiar stand is equally pleasing, in view of the outcry that the alien must be kept out of the country because he is a dangerous competitor. Unless the budget debates intervene, this measure will soon become law and the English traveller will have to choose between his personal dignity and the discomfort of the examination which will be necessary to make this new law operative. The alien may find salvation in the law-makers' refusal to submit to an inquisition entirely foreign to his nature; but this is a trifle compared with the general impression such a measure, even if it be impracticable, creates.

In that House of Commons which was once led by a Jew, at times presided over by & Jew; in that England in which the Jew has at times risen to almost dazzling heights, one of whose colonies is governed, “in the King’s name,” by a Jew; in London, where in years of great state and difliculty, the city’s honor and pride were entrusted to a Jew; there it is openly avowed that anti-Semitic pressure has forced the government to commit itself to anti-English legislation. The struggle to complete the enfranchisement of the English Jew occupied the energies of the Jews for two decades, the feeling of unalloyed freedom has been dissipated in half a century. Look at it how we will, it is a painful story and that the Jews in England feel the sting is evidenced by their attempt to battle for the alien, knowing full well that, if sometimes obscurely, his cause is linked together with their own.

Nor can we ascribe this rise of anti-Semitism in England to overt Jewish conduct. The voluminous report of the Alien Commission reveals nothing but a prejudice, which as such, should be naturally confined to a few streets; for if we grant overcrowding or competition as good causes for prejudice, this affects less than one hundred thou-

sand people (eight or nine thousand voters) in a population of over forty millions. And within these very areas the Jews have forced out the thieves' kitchen, with "the hordes Alsatia," and have lowered the income of the saloon, adding to the value of taxable property.

A reaction has undoubtedly taken place, and a reaction against the Jew, the effect of which must, of course, first be felt by that alien who is the subject of the same oppressive force in, what is denied him, the land of his birth. It must be dejecting to the least sensitive of us, even to him to whom this rejection offers the consolatory feeling of martyrdom, that the world by its conduct says in praise of our past and in despite of our living present: "We admire you afar off; we fear you and object to you when you are near us."

England has offset this by a generous offer to provide a home for our masses in East Africa. That offer becomes the less agreeable the more‘ we realize that it has been made because of a logical recognition of the need for opening some door if this nearest gate of refuge be barred. And this seems the one great reason why we should persuade ourselves to accept this offer. It is a departure from Zionism, and it would be best to keep it out of the line of Zionist operations; but the departure from our programme is no greater than is Western anti-Semitism from what Europe imagined itself to be less than ten years ago. While England is passing a law to restrict the infux of the alien, American politicians are agitating for laws that shall exceed in severity those at present in force at Ellis Island. Even such a philathropie body as the Charity Organization Society is assisting in the educational campaign, —and the rod smites the child. We find in the various reasons given for. further repressive measures a point against the immigrant is made of the slogan: America is our Zion and Washington our Jerusalem. He who wishes may play the ostrich, he who will may read, he will not run; the Jewish situation is too complex and too gloomy for such mental or physical exereise.