The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 2 · August 1904
95printed page
scan 33 of 48

to us as "our very good friend —— Pasha of Constantinople." He seemed to be not only a very pleasant gentleman but one exceedingly well informed, and he maintained fully his share of the evening's brilliant talk. This man, my friends informed me, was a Turkish spy sent by his Government to ascertain what was being done and contemplated at the Congress, and it was owing to his presence that Zionism was not discussed at the gathering.

Dr. Herzl's courtesy toward me personally was shown in connection with the debate on the East African proposition. My friends urged me to participate in the discussion, with the view of expressing the American attitude and explaining the existing condition of affairs in New York. I inquired as to the status of the list of contemplated speakers and found that more than forty delegates had already expressed a desire to speak. I thereupon declined to join in the discussion, on the ground that the Congress would be so weary of the long talk that no good could be accomplished by protracting it. When I entered the meeting hall, after the recess just prior to the opening of the great debate, Herzl, who was in the chair, signalled me to him and told me that if I desired to speak he would call on me as the fourth speaker, which he did, and it

was not until after the American view had been presented and translated into German by Nordau, that Herzl suggested that discussion be limited to five minutes for each speaker. My treasured souvenir of the Congress is a photograph of Herzl, autographed by him and inscribed to me.

His tremendous power as a debater was shown in his conflict with Treitsch and Nossig; particularly the former, who assailed everything the leader had done, and whose language at times was not strictly parliamentary. The temper of the Congress was such that, but for Herzl's intervention and request that the man be permitted to continue, he would not have been listened to. At the conclusion, Herzl took the stand to reply. Such satire, such invective, such oratory, I have never heard. He tore to shreds his opponent's argument. Now convulsed with laughter, now storming with applause, he moved that Congress in a way impossible to describe. It was one of the most magnificent triumphs I have ever witnessed. A similar triumph was his on the night when the Russians were about to secede and it was his great personality which won them back. Upon whose shoulders his mantle will fall and whether there be shoulders capable of carrying it, time alone can tell.

(Widmüngsblatt)

Zum Andenken meiner Schwester

Pauline Herzl

geb. 10 märz 1859, gest. 7 Febr 1878

gewidmet

[DEDICATION, IN DR. HERZL'S HANDWRITING, OF ALTNEULAND.]