and front of it in the form of the Jewish Colonization Association; he saw it in the colossal attitude of the millionaire Jew and sneered at him; he saw it in the impossibilities of orthodoxy and argued with it—he drew the paradox out of the past as Nordau has analyzed it in the present universal condition. Tracing this development, we have no reason to be impatient with him. Though in the organization, he is not an organization man; though preaching to the Jews on the need of a policy, he is himself a Jew, that is, not a disciplined politician. The Zionism of Zangwill has grown—it will continue to grow.
Delving into the lower depths of Jewish life, he sees the need for lighting “the torch of visible community”—and visible community is a Jewish state. The actual Menorah was lit anew by Theodor Herzl, who found that if it must be kept alight, only the oil with the scent of Zion would keep the wick aflame. Zangwill, too, sees this; but he has not yet had the master’s experience. Or, rather, he thinks we can succeed where Herzl failed of success by going back to Herzl’s “over there”—any free land—any plot of ground for a state.
The need for a gegenswart politik, a program to meet the present economic situation, impresses him. “You,” he says to communal and institutional Jewry, “You are seeking a new dumping ground for immigrants. So be it. But let us make it a state and restore the self-confidence and self-respect of the Jews.” No one may spurn the suggestion in the face of our growing critical situation; but after all, the Jew will find his true equilibrium in Zion. The destiny of the race is not settled either by logic or sentiment—destiny is an overshadowing force, felt and perceived; and it will not be the Jewish need that will make the real Jewish future. Zangwill sees that
—nay more, he feels it—he feels the Jewish life, it is beginning to stir in his veins.
Recently he let fall the sentence of feeling: “If we were not suffering, our national pride demands a state for the Jewish people.” Our national pride will content itself with nothing less than Zion. He wants a state anywhere as a step to Zion, as a big school ground for the development of practical nationalism, as a pied a terre from which real Zionism can work for Zionistic Zionism. And when someone asked him, “But you say the gates of Palestine are closed to us?” He replied, “They are; but I believe that if the three richest Jews in the world agreed, we could get Palestine in a few years.” With that he comes back to one of the thoughts of his “Children of the Ghetto,” a thought that presses on the heart more than in the mind of the Jew.
“Had the Jew only come so far only to break down at last, sinking in morasses of modern doubt, and irresistibly dragging down with the Christian and the Moslem; or was he yet fated to outlast them both, in continuous testimony to a hand moulding incomprehensibly the life of humanity?”
This question, addressed by Zangwill to the millionaires, has its justification in the Zionistic advances of the questioner. That he is a type of the Jewish paradox in many things matters not. He, too, committed “the blasphemy of this time,” as George Eliot called looking on, and to what measure these millionaires look on no one can say. Zangwill himself has still to reach out to the deeper truth, the overmastering feeling to which the wealthy must come, not because they are rich but because they are Jews. We must “choose the full heritage,” and destiny hurries us to the fulfillment of the vision—Zion.