the rich landowners, the wealthy city merchants, the peasants. The declared revolutionists remain in the background, but there can be no question but that the menace of their presence is duly felt. It may be that the ideas they have so long risked their lives for will ultimately be carrıed into effect bv other hands than
theirs. It is their fight, nevertheless, that the people, acting through their provincial assemblies, have entered into against the organized iniquity of the bureaucracy, —their fight, and the fight of all the weak within the empire as well as of freedom and justice everywhere.
Herzl, the Real Jew
BY J. DE HAAS
In one of the most remarkable appreciations of Herzl, written immediately after his death, and penned by one of the foremost men in the cultur wing, it was set forth in so many words, that Theodor Herzl had come to the Zionist movement, had helped to reconstruct it, but was himself not of the heart of the Jewish people. The thought is not wholly a new one. As far back as 1898, a writer in a London newspaper described him as the Parnell of the Jews, one who had obtained a political control from without, but did not spring from the masses whom he really sought to aid. The observation was further emphasized in Ost und West, by a picture of Herzl the poet, side by side with another of the more deeply featured Herzl, the Jew. Zionism had made him the latter.
In so far as the facts of his personal life go, the criticism was true enough. Herzl sprang from the fairly well-to-do, from the element fairly long tolerated if not wholly enfranchised, and had Sephardic blood in his veins. This is neither the political nor the family history of our masses. But the personal history of those who were able to lend a real helping hand to the Jews during the nineteenth century is not the his-
tory of the masses, so that we are confronted by a remarkable situation. Neither Moses Montefiore, Cremieux, Lionel de Rothschild, Mordecai Noah, Edmond de Rothschild, Disraeli, Herzl, none of these came from the masses. True enough, Pinsker, Smolenski, Lilienbaum and Achad Ha'am come from the masses, but no one can imagine that they, or even Hess, would have been remembered if the enthusiasm of Herzl had not called the Zionistic history into life. And to-day, when the Zionists are calling for a new leader, their eyes are turned everywhere but to the centres where the masses can give leadership.
The obvious deduction is, of course, this: Not that Jewish leaders cannot arise from the masses, but that the political environment in which the masses live prevents such leaders from rising and claiming their rights. This, I say, is the obvious deduction, but I do not say that it is the right one. I hesitate to say it, but I believe that Herzl was the real Jew; and the masses, not so real, came to him as a people shall always come when they see their great standard set up.
The real Jew? What is he? There is a reform and an orthodox view, but reform is a poor new thing that does