The Maccabæan
EDITORIAL PAGES J. DE HAAS, Editor
JEWS AND DISPERSION
Most of our views of history are wild-eyed. We talk of the Jewish dispersion, and of the scattering that went hand in hand with dispersion, in no uncertain fashion as having gone on and on since the destruction of the Second Temple. Very telling phrases can be evolved on the Wandering Jew, and so far have we wandered that Menassah ben Israel already thought the scattering complete when he faced Cromwell with the petition for the readmission of the Jews into England. Yet the Jewish movement, that is the movement of the Jews, proceeded at a snail's pace until well into the nineteenth century.
It is of course true, according to Kaufmann, that a Jew accompanied Columbus on the voyage to America and much earlier in history we have records of Jewish settlements in India, in China and Arabia. But having crossed the Mediterranean at the order of Titus the Jews cannot be said to have scattered freely or quickly. The movement of the mass is easily definable. It was naturally limited for centuries to Europe, but even there was confined to central Europe, stretching slowly to the Northwest, concentrating in the centre of the great plain and bulging over at length towards the East and becoming politically Russians. Setting aside the adventurous spirits who went to Canada and Brazil, and who founded the North American communities, we believe history will show that the Jews resisted movement and migration rather than favored it.
Steam and electricity have helped the whole world to move rapidly since the middle of the last century but even these did not carry the Jews forward in proportion to their need or their historic character. What most of us have to understand in our glib discussions of Jewish history and the condition of the Jews is that the real dispersion began about 1875 and assumed great proportions in 1882 and has been proceeding in volume ever since. The balance of Jewry is still in Europe and the smallest numbers are to be found the greatest distance from the old center. That is why the yoke of the burden has changed and has become heavier: things are not as they were, and we must remove the imaginary world and imaginary history away to realize the facts.
POSSIBILITIES.
And this brings us to a speculative thought. The average modern Jew boggles at the suggestion—a Jewish state. Impossible, he says, because it was never done before. There are historic reasons why the Palestinean state was not reattempted, but no one can easily say why the Jews did not attempt to found states during the last four hundred years, of opportunities and occasions there was no end. It is difficult for instance to understand why the first or second generation of the descendants of the Spanish exodus did not think of the New World instead of becoming petty traders in Amsterdam. Why did not the English Jews in 1750 when they were suffering from Jew-baiting think of claiming a corner of the world for themselves? Why did not the Russian Jews after the Cossack outrages of the middle of the 17th century move East and make a state in the Parnirro? Why did it not occur to Mendelssohn at the beginning of the nine-