The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
93printed page
scan 11 of 52

upon the East African proposal are premature while we are still without the report of the Commission. If that report be not favorable—if the Commissioners tell us that the territory is unfitted as a centre of Jewish settlement—the conditions which the plan seeks to mitigate will be in no wise improved. Our movement will be still face to face with one of its gravest dangers—one that, I fear, has, in some quarters, been actually hailed as its sheet-anchor, and is too often regarded with equanimity from, of course, not the human, but from the nationalist, point of view.

That danger is the constantly-growing acuteness of the Jewish position in the world.

There is no need for me to enter here into detail upon the Jewish position, but whether we regard the state of those of our people who are still in Russia and Poland, or of the large majority who have migrated to America and Western lands, and the attitude manifested towards them, we cannot look to the future with equanimity, or without the very keenest anxiety.

It is contended that the state in which our people find themselves is a matter for philanthropy, with which a national movement has no concern. I join issue. The constant persecution of our people, the position to which they are subjected, often by Jews themselves, when they make an effort to release themselves from their condition, must, if continued, result in a serious depreciation of the raw material out of which, it is hoped, the Jewish nation is to be rebuilt. Here is, clearly, matter for concern to those who are striving to rebuild the Jewish Nation. Nor is the depreciation merely physical and material. This constant menace to life and being have the tendency to beat out of men the

aspiration for nationality in its practical form. The immediate necessities of existence come first as most urgent, and, by the time they are secured, material advantages obscure finer aims. Thus, so many of our people, when once they reach even moderate prosperity and freedom, with their past imprinted on their souls, so anxiously cling to these personal advantages. So fearful are they of losing them, that they will not even consider the higher needs and aspirations of their fellow-Jews. Nay, their one anxiety is to identify themselves, politically and socially, with other nations, and, at best, only on the human side, with Jewry. They perceive the former strong and prosperous, the latter weak, dispersed, and the ivy ever will trail itself round the oak. Can we who seek to rebuild the Jewish nation ignore and regard as of no account this constant impulse to Jewish denationalization?

But there are those who seem to think that it is just Jewish persecution and the status which Jews occupy in the world which will gain us our ends—that the force of circumstances will compel the nations of the world to give Palestine to the Jews. This may well be, but I hope otherwise. I hope Palestine will be opened to Jews, rather, as a result of their demand for a political existence for its own sake, than as an exit from the violence of persecution. For, a far better prospect for the permanence of a regenerated, renationalized, Jewry will present itself if the former, and not the latter, be the immediate prelude to the realization of our people's hopes. I say this by the way, but we have constantly to guard against the Zionist ranks being manned by those whose motives are merely philanthropic, and not by those whose motives are, in the largest sense, political.

If this view is accepted, then it would,