retically is declared to be the pride of our republic, there may develop a recrudescence of "racial and religious rage, with the result of reawakening and deepening the old antipathy." We are solemnly informed that at a dinner of seventy-five New York clergymen last week "this Dewey matter was talked over, and much feeling was expressed. Old stories against the Jews were resurrected, and I heard more talk of this kind at that meeting than I heard in the previous ten years of clergymen's meetings which I have attended."
From what you say, the table talk of these men of God could have been "but little of the Bible." They cannot have "resurrected" stories of the Hebrew prophets, nor could their conversation have been of the Psalms, or of Job, or of the Sayings of the Fathers, or of Hillel or Akiba, of the Talmud, or of the poets, and moralists and philosophers, who for twenty centuries of persecution unequalled in the annals of man, kept alive the spiritual heritage of the world, and created a literature of which the Jewish Encyclopedia (of which you are justly proud), is now giving to the world a slight glimpse, while their persecutors were but savages and barbarians. Were the old stories that you clerical dinner companions "resurrected" at that memorable feast the shameful superstitions of medieval bigotry, stories of the black death, of poisoned wells, of the horrible blood accusations? Did they brand us as Shylocks, or as Fagins, or retail the stories of the Inquisition, of the Procurator of the Holy Synod, of Esterhazy, or of the redoubtable Count Pueckler?
You may tell your theological friends that, while we are shocked at your disclosure, we are not dismayed; that, while we grieve at such a manifestation of what is sometimes termed an un-Christian spirit, it is not a new experience with us; that, while we recognize that the millennium has not yet sounded in quarters where its notes might be first expected to be discerned, we who have been accustomed to exercise patience can persevere for another thousand years.
if need there be; and that, while we would gladly enjoy the fruits of peace and prosperits, rather than surrender our principles or our conscience, or what we conceive to be truth and right and justice, we, who are the descendants of those whose lives meant suffering, would not even shrink from martyrdom.
Your disclosure is most valuable. It tells us where we stand. It warns us that we cannot afford to loll at our ease, and permit the establishment of a dangerous and nefarious precedent. It teaches us the oft-told, but too often forgoten precept, that "he who would be free himself must strike the blow."
And now, a word with reference to your suggestion, that we withdraw our petition, "in order to gain credit for self-restraint, moderation and public spirit." We have been smitten on the right cheek, and are told to turn the left to the smiter. It is an exercise to which we have become accustomed by the practice of centuries. It has, however, grown somewhat monotonous. Your clerical friends, and Mr. Dewey, who believe that by prescriptive right they may do all the smiting, are astonished that the smitten should cease to feel comfortable in the abject humiliation to which they should been inured. You forget that the glory of American citizenship has aroused the consciousness of manhood. You ask us to be magnanimous, and once more to assume our wonted attitude. From Mr. Dewey there is no word of regret for the wrong that has been done; no apology; no recantation; nothing but patronizing and nauseating slobber. We must kiss the hand that strikes the blow; we must exercise self-restraint; while your clerical friends stand by and raise not one word of protest, of indignation, or of admonition, but, on the contrary, voice the gospel of hate, of intolerance, and of bigotry.
No; the petition will not be withdrawn. If there had ever been any doubt as to the course to be pursued, your letter has solved it effectually.
Yours very truly, LOUIS MARSHALL.