tives and their right to act on behalf of the Jews had no other sanction than their own consciences. No one can doubt that they meant well; no one can question the motive of men who have voluntarily denied themselves busines profits which would come to them if they did not refuse patriotically to trade with Russia. But when all this said, when every eulogy has been recited, the Jewish people have rights that go beyond the best individual motives.
Two great elements are concerned in this problem, the Russian Jews for whom the deputation spoke; the American Jews, whose opinions the deputation supposedly represented. Neither was consulted by the deputation; probably because of this the deputation failed practically. M. Witte smiled when they came; he smiled still more when they left—his smile will broaden itself in Russian policy for the next five years.
No one can prevent any individual from widening himself with a public task, but he can refuse to become party to a contract made without his consent. And this is the position of the Jewish people. It was not a party to the deputation, and the wider this is realised the better for the interests of the Jews.
Had the Jewish people been consulted the organised elements in Russia and in the United States it would most likely have rejected the proposal to seek the in terview, and it would probably have de clined to wait upon a Rusisan Minister who, being out of his national jurisdiction, could play more fast or loose with matters abroad than he even does at home. Had it been con sulted the Jewish people might have de clined to make known to M. Witte those facts of Russo-Jewish life which M. Witte and the Czar probably know better than any deputation of Jews. Had it been consulted the Jewish people might in principle have rejected the ancient and useless idea of petitioning a Minister.
The people primarily concerned are the
Rusiian Jews; had they been consulted they might have urged the American Jews to leave all high politics alone and enable them, by financial aid, to fight out their battle at home as revolutionists. Or they might have asked for help in an ex-Russian emancipation movement. Had they been first consulted the bulk of American Jews might have replied that the line of policy to be adopted in treating with the government of Russia must be set forth in no uncertain terms, by the Jews in Russia.
As it is, the deputation has rather injured than improved the position of the Jews in Russia; it has made the Jews more and more "foreigners," and "aliens" in their native state; a people for whom action is taken from the outside, and who, therefore, have no power of acting from within. The Russian government has in the deputation a weapon that will appeal to every patriotic Russian, and a weapon that the patriot is already using—in the renewed massacres.
It is time the Jewish house was set in order so that those who argue with governments on behalf of their brethren should have the ambassadorial sanction of organised opinion behind them; and, moreover, so tht governments shall understand that when they wish to deal with us they can only approach our delegated representatives, and not merely high spirited and noble-minded representative Jews. We should be only too glad to see Mr. Schiff and Mr. Oscar Straus elected to carry out a Jewish policy—but it must be a policy that has the sanction of the people who elect them to bear their messages to the nations.
England’s Offer.
"I am to state that any endeavor to ameliorate the condition and raise the status of the Jewish People will always command the sympathy and goodwill of the British Government." So writes the British Government to Mr. L. J. Greenberg, and such an expresseion justifies all that has happened in connection with the East African