scholars scarcely one knew the date of Aaron's death, which is expressly given in the Bible (11), while everyone of them knew that Moses died on the seventh day of Adar, which is merely a guess of the Talmud (12). Such a method the Gaon opposed. Raphael Hamburger, when asked wherein lay the greatness of the Gaon, pointed to the Bible, saying that the knowledge of that book and the revival of Jewish interest in it, is to a large extent due to him. Instead of familiarizing himself with the Bible through the numerous quotations from it in the Talmud, he, unlike the other Talmudists of the time, attained to the knowledge of it by reading the Bible itself. In his later days, we are informed by David Lurie (13), he studied nothing but the Pentateuch, inserting, as he read, the various Talmudical interpretations and later rabbinical views; a thing which was possible for him to do, as he was thoroughly familiar both with the Bible and the whole rabbinical literature (14).
Having revived interest in the Bible, he also restored the long-neglected study of Hebrew (15), on which subject he wrote a book. He likewise created an interest in the Tosephto, the Mechilto, Siphri, and Siphro, and also in the Palestinian Talmud, which he corrected and clarified. In all of his commentaries, and he wrote one on almost every book of the Bible, he lays great stress on the true and grammatical understanding of the text. He submitted all sacred literature to the same philological method of study which is applied to secular literature. With a single reference to a parallel passage, or with a textual emendation, he very often tears down the air-
acquaintance with the various branches of Jewish literature made it possible for him to explain a great many obscure and difficult passages in the Bible and Talmud. He sought to elucidate obscure passages in the Mishnah by citing parallel passages from the Tosephto. The difficult passages in the Babylonian Talmud he tried to explain by reference to the corresponding old and simpler passages in the Palestinian Talmud.
The Gaon's attitude to Kabbalah is hard to define. Graetz finds fault with him because he believed in such Kabbalistic works as the Zohar, etc. But if we consider the conditions of the time, we shall be apt to criticise him less severely for his leanings towards Kabbalah. This much at any rate is certain, that though he did not reject Kabbalah, and even wrote a commentary on the Zohar, he was not influenced by it as were his contemporaries. He did, indeed, accept the good side of its teachings, namely, to shun worldly and sensuous pleasures; but aside from this, the Talmud alone was his guide (16). That he wrote a commentary on the Zorah does not argue anything in regard to his attitude towards its teachings; for he did not expect his writings to be published. His works were originally merely notes to his readings. These "jottings" were later found so valuable and complete as to warrant their publication in a more permanent form. But we may not conclude from this that he accepted the teachings of the books upon which he commented, any more than we could conclude in the case of a modern Jewish scholar that he accepted Christianity because he had made some glosses to a New Testament text. We have other proof, too, if the testimony of an opponent may be relied upon, that he did not have any strong leanings towards Kabbalah. A letter (17) of one of the Chassidic saints,
(11). Numbers xxxiii:38.
(12). Kiddushin, 38b.
(13). Ma'aloth Hasulom, 29.
(14). In the Bible he could, according to Lurie, enumerate all the "vavs" and "yods" of each chapter.
(15). Neglected, no doubt, partly in opposition to the over-emphasis on this subject by the Karaites.
castles of his predecessors. His thorough
(16). Cf., Cahan, "Eben Ophel," and "Hashchar," vol. V (1874), pp. 639-643.
(17). In a Chassidic MS., now in the possession of Ephraim Deinard.