before they could understand them, he was able to read at a glance. He was once shown one of the inexplicable midrashim which read as follows:
אִין מִנִּיחִין תַּפְלִין אִלֹּא בְּשׁבַּתand without any hesitation he explained it to mean:
„בְּמִקְוָם שֵׁעַר, בְּמִקְוָם תַּפּוּח“(which are indeed the right places for the “tephilin”). When Eibenschuetz's Urim Vetumin appeared, one of the Gaon's disciples, who had a strong inclination towards pilpulism, found delight in studying it, and often praised the work of the Gaon. One day Elijah asked him to select what he thought the most subtle discourse in the book, and recite it. The disciple chose a very long and intricate discussion which he repeated to his teacher. When he had finished, Elijah said to him: “If we wished to engage in such worthless work, life would be much too short to accomplish anything, for in this same argument we could add”—and here the Gaon prolonged the discussion so much, and in so skillful a manner, that his hearer could scarcely follow it.
R. Loeb, the author of שאגת אריה once delivered a pilpulistic lecture which was very much admired by the scholars of Wilna. On the following day the Gaon delivered one in which he proved that leaven was permitted on the Passover. After he had finished, his hearers crowded around him, overwhelming him with questions as to whether the laws regarding
לֹא תַאַכַל עַלִין חַמִּץ ought to be abolished. He then opened the Bible and pointed to the express command (28)) אַתְּכַל עַלִין חַמִּץ adding: This is the truth of the matter, the other was fiction.
Herr Schulman, of Buechow, once visited the Gaon. After he had introduced himself, the Gaon asked him—he was a grammarian of great renown—whether he could take some mishnaic passage and vocalize it. Schulman not being able to do this, was asked to select a passage for the purpose
(28). Deut. xvi:3.
of testing the Gaon in a similar way, and the Gaon without hesitation correctly vocalized the text thus chosen for him (20).
His disciple, R. Chayim, once asked him why, in addition to the ordinary phylacteries, he did not don the "tephilin" of Rabbenu Tam in order to be on the safe side. If this were necessary, said Elijah, why not have sixty-four different kinds of "tephilin," since there are that many different views in the Talmud as to the proper method of making them?
In his commentary on the Shulchan Aruch he often shows a better knowledge of the sources of the various religious practices than does Joseph Caro himself; and in his notes and textual criticisms on the Tosephto and the Seder Olam he restores the correct texts more frequently than do those who were able to avail themselves of the MSS.
These are but a few illustrations of the phenomenal powers of the Gaon. Many more might be cited to show that in him were found, in rare combination, those qualities of mind and heart which constitute what we know as genius. And well for Lithuania that such a master came at a time when he was most needed.
CHAPTER IV.
The Gaon’s Opposition to Chassidism.
PILPULISM was not the only source of mischief for the Jews of the Gaon's time. A far greater evil was now rapidly spreading, which threatened to gain a powerful hold upon the Jew of Lithuania—namely, Chassidism.
Just how this movement originated is not known. It could not have been, as has been suggested by some (30), a revolt against the excessive casuistry of the contemporary rabbis; nor could its origin have been due to the extreme rigorism of the Talmudists. In either case, as has been
(29). Ben Poroth, p. 67, Wilna, 1858.
(30). E. g., Graetz and Schechter.