before the riots began. In many, the majority, of cases the self-defense corps were unprepared for the assault. They did not imagine that the joy of the celebration of the constitution would in an hour be turned into unforgettable sorrow. Nevertheless they fought as Jews fought in Bethar, in Jerusalem and at Beth Horon. The spirit of resistance is good; it must be supported. If the Jews must go down in death, let them go down fighting. If resistance means a holocaust, it is better, it is more humane, that an end be made to Jewish suffering in one vast catastrophe rather than that passivity should result in a harassing of our people which will destroy them physically as well as mentally, which means a slow instead of a quick death. Our people are in a trap in Russia—they have the moral and the legal right to defend themselves. To give to the Self Defense Association means trying to save lives and sparing mothers and daughters from violation.
The Remedy.
We have tried to set it all down dispassionately, for it is an hour in which the brain must strive more than the heart. We frankly believe that there is no hope for the Jews in Russia. Revolution or counter-revolution will destroy them. Russia must go through a struggle, and in that struggle the Jews must continually suffer. A repetition of the massacres will not raise another five million dollars; in a year such incidents will appear as the normal incidents in the political struggles of the Russian empire. Relief will not only fail, relief can effect nothing but the assuaging of immediate hunger and homelessness, if that. Zionism must come forward, not as a moral but as a political force; it must be taken up where Herzl let the work slip through his dead fingers; we must strive for a free home for the Jewish people. But not merely as Zionists, not as a party. The Jewish world must be called into congress country by country—the burden and responsibility of the solving of the Jewish problem must be put on every one, rich and poor alike, without distinction of partisanship, affiliation or sectional difference. There must be a congress here in the United States, then in England, Germany, France and so on. The will of the Jewish people must be declared, and that will must become the moral principle of Jewish life. This done there will be a way
out. For there is no scheme so fantastic that the will and money of a people shall not carry out—and that which the congress of all the congresses shall decide upon will be far from fantastic—it will be means of human salvation of a people who stand alone in the world.
Hanucha.
IT will be difficult this year to chant the Mo'uz T'zur this year with other than pursed lips. It is no song of triumph that the Jewish people will sing this year. Mourning and not joy is the note of the hour, and even such exceptional anniversaries as the 250th anniversary of the Settlement of the Jews in North America and in England have been overshadowed by the wail of grief. Let it were idle to misuse the opportunity which the calendar automatically presents to us. We face a festival which is practically unencumbered by religious rites, and which has survived brilliantly notwithstanding that the lack of these safeguards.
The recovery of Jerusalem by the Hasmoneans is likely a very dim suggestion to our modern minds; the ancient restoration of the temple has but a metaphorical meaning to our generation. And yet the Feast of Lights survive! Judaism, it is true, is an impersonal religion, yet in the human breast there always is that chord which is ready to respond to a brave and personal deed. The festival has. therefore, always been a tribute to the unique brain of a lovable group of men. We know little enough of them. We see them as soldiers, politicians, priests and statesmen, they rise to a giant stature within a short space of time and disappear even before the first glory of their achievements has approached its Zenith, and yet they live, and their lives thrill us. We still see that first outburst of revolt, that rash act at Modin that brought the passive Jews together in defiance as well as in defense, and recognize the rapid growth of that movement, which all against odds won the victory for God, country and faith. Brave and strong men these, and ever since our strong men have been likened to Hasmoneans, and our heroes have received the Guerdon of this ancient praise. It is well it is so, and if there is sorrow in the camp of Israel, there is cause for triumph, too, for in a humble way men have sacrificed their lives in Russia with the same impetuous bravery as was manifested in the Judean halls of old, and at even greater orders.
We can afford to let the old lights glisten anew, for if the stress is as great as it was there when Mattathias first planted the standard of revolt, there is even, though more dimly discernable, a rallying to our standard. For a hundred years past Jews have not cried so earnestly "let us come together," and in this cry is hope and strength. Let the little lights twinkle their happy message of victory—for victory there must come to all who have strength of faith and the courage that endures.