The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 1 · January 1906
9printed page
scan 15 of 54

not resembling him in perfection will at least equal him in love of race and in ardour for the national cause." The direct purpose of "Daniel Deronda" is partially suggested in the letter to Prof. Kaufmann. It is more distinctly set forth in the novel itself in the eloquent addresses of Mordecai Cohen, his enthusiasm for race and fatherland, his ideal of a national polity so powerful in its claims that all sectarian differences shall be set aside in the endeavour to restore Israel to Zion. He argues from the national, the political, the ethnic, the social, the spiritual, and the philosophic points of view, but the traditional idea of Zion-Restored, the religious idea, is submerged. George Eliot put into the mouth of the man who was to charm her hero back to Judaism, the theories and the burning hopes of Political Zionism; but Political Zionism was not then, and was only born exactly two decades later. "Daniel Deronda," the fiction was first made known to the world in April, 1876. "Daniel Deronda," a political possibility, was announced in April, 1896. The coincidence of dates is only of relative interest, but the sequence is of first rate importance, for it is this which stamps the book as unique in English Literature, and entitles its author to be regarded as a seer amongst writers.

Sydney Grier's "Kings of the East" (Blackwood) approaches the same subject from the political side, but it is a roman au clef. In one way or the other the new doctrine has percolated to every strata of society, thanks to strenuous agitation—hence Grier's book is a natural effect in the realm of political fiction of the thoughts of a notable element in actual life. Most novels with a purpose answer to the same definition. They depict what is and foreshadow what is still in the realm of thought. Imagination is at best but the embroidery of what exists: in the same way as the grotesque is only the combination of actual extremes. The whole range of mythological god-men and god-beast, only offers fantastic combinations. The highest altitude of conjecture is attained by the aid of some thin structure of truth that is. In its true sense inspiration is the conception of what consciously is not. This gift we must accord to George Eliot. The message of her "Daniel Deronda" had no truth in the life around the

author; it was in sooth a parable for the future, and her powers are not a wit lessened if it is realised that a single word put into a child's mouth "Shabbesfyock" (Sabbath frock) proves that the author had studied the Jews from life and at close quarters. A critical generation is loth to permit any man or woman to don the mantle of prophet—but the writer cannot beg George Eliot doff it. There is nothing in the life of this woman born in the English Midlands who unlearnt Christianity and attacked philosophic speculation with masculine capacities, to show who or what prompted a thought, new to her generation. Could she have captured even a stray idea from current Jewish life? In 1876 and before that date the Jews in England were a self-satisfied community. Largely ignorant of the normal condition of their brethren abroad they were almost wholly wrapt in the repose that came after the final step in emancipation—the removal of the Test Acts. Mr. Joseph Jacobs, who endeavoured to explain the lack of sympathy on the part of critics, tells us (Macmillan, Nov., 1876.) "English Judaism is without signs of life." Only one English Jew had returned his footsteps to Zion. Sir Moses Montefiore, and his was the religious sentimental attitude, a hope of miniature resettlement as a pledge of the continuance of the old oath: "If I forget thee, Oh Jerusalem! let my right hand forget its cunning," nothing more. The year in which "Daniel Deronda" was written and published in parts saw Benjamin d'Israeli rise to the very first rank as an English statesman and despite his conversion the Jews felt no little satisfaction at the event. D'Israeli had seen the Jewish vision of the return in "Alroy," but cloyed it with mysticism and wrote it as the story of a failure. In all Jewry but few men had thought of the return seriously. Steinschneider, the great Hebrew philologist, with Dr. Benisch and Dr. Albert Lowy and Charles Netter had only advocated colonisation; both then in England had thought of it, but they had brushed aside the dreams of student youth and had hardly dreamt of political restoration. Cremieux returned in 1844 to France after the "Damascus Blood Accusation" and had such an idea, but it remained in a nebulous condition and within the possible range of George Eliot's reading there