The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 2 · February 1906
53printed page
scan 17 of 52

senes to Orphic and Pythagorean influences, nor the scepticism of the Sadducees to Epicurean tendencies, for it is quite possible to trace both to native sources. Profound religious experiences always give rise, under certain conditions, to some degree of asceticism; and it is doubtful how far the Sadducaic scepticism was not a manifestation of conservatism in the interests of old heresies. As for the renegade Jews, all that is necessary to explain their treason, is the ordinary, vulgar motive of the worship of success, the promptings of ambition, and the attraction of sensual indulgence. Only in a very minor degree could the glamour of Greek art and literature have affected them. The example of these could have no great force for the mass of the people. The antagonism of Judea and Hellas was far too fundamental, and manifested itself at too many points. The antagonism and the resultant struggle was all the more fierce, because of certain traits common to both. The first of these was the extreme strength of the communal bond. Within Hellas there was a ready surrender of the individual on the part of the body of the citizens. In democratic Athens the banishment of Aristides was voted for, because forsooth, he was "the Just." Socrates refused to avail himself of the means of escape from death, because that would be acting against the laws of his State. In Plato's Utopian "Politeia" there is scarcely more freedom for the individual than in oligarchic Sparta, which served largely for Plato's model. While such conditions may have affected adversely the development of individuality, they conferred tremendous power and effectivity upon the Greek State for defense and aggression.

Within Jewry, individuality was from the earliest days intensely developed. This could easily be discerned by comparing the laws of Mishpatim with the code of Hammurabi. In paragraph 210 of the latter (Winckler's Edition) the murderer of a

woman is punished by the slaying of the murderer's daughter. In paragraph 230 the builder of a house, who by his inefficient work had caused the death of the son of the owner of the house, was punished by the slaying of his own son. Yet when the Jew was at his best the communal bond was as strong as that of the Greek, but it was of different psychological origin. It did not arise from the repression, but from the development of individuality. It was the profound realization of individuality giving force to the demands of the conscience, making the salvation of the soul the end of life, urging the expiation of sin, and atonement unto God, which marshalled the Jews together to the defense of the Temple, of the Torah, of the Holy Land where the Jews for purposes of self-defense dwelt in the Schechinah and united into one body.

A second trait common to the two waspride of race. The lecturer illustrated indetail the operation of race pride in theheart of the Greek. The Greek faced therest of the world—the barbarians—withcontempt and merciless hostility. The Jewin his pride of race was certainly equal tothe Greek, but under normal conditionsthere was in the soul of the Jew neithercontempt nor hostility for other men, onlythe liveliest sense of his importance to themand responsibility toward them. Israel wasthe servant whom God had chosen to be"for a covenant of the people, for a lightof the Gentiles, to open the blind eyes andto bring out the prisoners from the prison."He was the bearer of God's truth to therest of the human world, who were all thechildren of God. Nevertheless, the Jew'sheart bounded with pride that upon hisbrow was written "Holiness to the Lord."It was inevitable that conflict terrible andlong-continued should break forth betweenHellas and Judea. This was hastened andembittered by the conflicting conceptionsof freedom.

The lecturer, after analyzing with con-