Congress and Conference
The American Congress idea has made no direct progress during the month, but it has been the cause of considerable discussion. The New York Judeans debated the issue inconclusively, but this debate was overshadowed by the publication in the Hebrew Standard of a confidential circular issued by Messrs. Louis Marshall, Cyrus L. Sulzberger, Judge Greenbaum, Nathan Bijur, and Joseph Jacobs, as secretary, inviting a number of gentlemen to meet and discuss the formation of a national Jewish committee, which has been considered as the direct possible outcome of the congress planned by some of the national organizations. The Hebrew Standard attacked the convening of this conference, the American Hebrew mildly rebuked it, for not operating on a broader basis, and the Jewish Daily News, which has attacked the President of the Executive Committee of the I. O. B. B. for opposing the congress idea, met the conference in a spirit of intense hostility, and on the evening of its first session, by its invitation, brought several hundred people to the United Hebrew Charities Building as would-be witnesses and participants in the debate. Unofficially it is known that the conference lasted some 14 hours, and that the most difficult issue turned on the race versus faith question. The prime mover urged that recognition be given on the basis of congregational representation, whilst the Nationalists claimed that the committee should be elected or appointed by
a much wider constituency. A committee to effect a compromise was finally appointed. The official report of the conference is as follows:
A meeting was held on Saturday evening, February 3d, and a morning and afternoon session on Sunday, February 4th, at the Hebrew Charities Building, to consider the advisability of forming a general Jewish Committee in the United States.
There were present 34 gentlemen of the 55 invited from the most important centers of the Jewish population throughout the country, as follows: Baltimore—Dr. Harry Friedenwald; Boston—Lehman Pickert; Chicago—Dr. Emil G. Hirsch, Adolf Kraus, Hon. Julian W. Mack, Dr. J. Stolz; Louisville—Dr. H. G. Enelow; Milwaukee—A. W. Rich; Newark—Felix Fuld; New Orleans—Dr. M. Heller, Dr. J. L. Leucht; New York—N. Alenikoff, Nathan Bijur, Hon. S. Greenbaum, Prof. Joseph Jacobs, Dr. Kaplan, E. W. Lewin-Epstein, Prof. Morris Loeb, Dr. J. L. Magnes, Louis Marshall, Dr. H. P. Mendes, J. Saphirstein, Hon. Jacob H. Schiff, Abraham S. Schomer, Hon. Oscar S. Straus, Cyrus L. Sulzberger; Providence—Harry Cutler; Philadelphia—Jacob Gimbel, Hon. Mayer Sulzberger; Richmond—Dr. E. N. Calisch; San Francisco—O. J. Wise; Washington—Dr. Cyrus Adler, Hon. Simon Wolf.
The meeting, after being called to order by Mr. Louis Marshall, one of the original summoners of the Conference, elected Hon. Mayer Sulzberger Chairman and Prof. Joseph Jacobs Secretary.