concerning all sorts of commentaries, technicalities, and old liturgies, which would not be wissed even had they never existed. There we have a palpable example before us how deeply the longing for some positive national ideal is ingrained in these learned men, an ideal which shall give their love for their people a legal basis and make it possible for them to devote themselves to its spiritual problems. Unhappily, there was no such ideal to be found, and they had to be contented with tombstones and old liturgies. Others who sought, but in vain, turned "backwards" to the old camp, others, again,
put up with the void, or were irrevocably lost.
These various movements were repeated with trifling alterations in the countries of Eastern Europe. But what learned men sought there without success was brought about here spontaneously by circumstance: "A moderate theory," able to restore the balance between old and new, "which should present both under a new aspect." We look with astonishment at this "aspect" which, without any sophistry, is comprehensible to all, and we are only surprised that it should have been so long in making its appearance.
Is it necessary to mention its name, or to point towards the East, to the Land of our Fathers?
Texts Illustrative of Early Zionist Projects
COLLECTED BY GEORGE ALEXANDER KOHUT
I.
An Anonymous Nationalist Plea of 1798.
The approaching 90th birthday of Professor Moritz Steinschneider—whom I am privileged to call master—recalls the early revival of the nationalistic idea, which owes its impetus not alone to the earnest and enthusiastic propaganda made by Jehuda Alkalay, Moses Hess, Leo Pinsker, and others, who are held to be the first pioneers of later-day Zionism, but, in an equal measure, to the unrecorded efforts of Abraham Benisch, Alfred Lowy and Moritz Steinschneider, who, while fellow-students at Prague, in the early thirties of the last century, zealously strove to promote the cause of the Restoration of Zion. It is not the purpose of these lines to set forth in detail (See G. A. Kohut, Moritz Steinschneider, N. Y., 1900, pp. 14-15.) the doings of this learned triumvirate—two of whom, close and life-long friends as they are, celebrate the 90th anniversary of their birth, almost at the same time. Far more is it designed to show that the beginnings of the
nationalist movement are to be sought in no one period of history, and that at all times and in all places there have arisen dreamers of Zion, who have striven to bring about the Return, and whose endeavors have hitherto found but scant recognition.
It is of such projects, visionary and immature though they seem, that we shall speak in the following chapters, which lay no claim to completeness, in any sense. They are put together, haphazard, from various sources, and it is to be hoped that even in their unsystematic form, they will furnish interesting and valuable material to the future historian of Zionism.
The first of the series of extracts to be published is a letter which is remarkable for its vigor of style, no less than for its practical appeal. It emphasizes the need of organization, thus sounding an almost contemporaneous note, and outlines a scheme of national salvation, which might well bear the date of the current year, though conceived as early as 1798. Altogether it is a document of great interest, meriting preser-