The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 6 · June 1906
216printed page
scan 16 of 50

king of the Chazars is an historical personage, who ruled over a people of Turkish origin in Southern Russia. His conversion to Judaism took place about 620 or 740 C. E., the date is disputed. According to some authorities not only the king and his court, but the whole people, became Jews, and were very zealous in erecting schools for the study of the Torah throughout their kingdom. The religious disputations in the court of Bulan suggested an effective form for an argumentative work like that which Jehudah Halevi had in mind.

According to the book the king wasgranted a vision in which an angel appeared, telling him that, although his intentions in seeking God were good, hisreligious practices were not pleasing toGod.

This troubled the king, and it was in order to find a solution to these difficulties that he summoned the disputants to his court.

At first they did not include a representative of the Jews, because, as the king himself explains, from the insignificance of their number, and the misery of their condition, he had inferred the worthlessness of their faith.

The philosopher can give the king no comfort at all. The God of philosophers is self-contained and self-thinking, he himself is the sole object of his thoughts. He can know only himself, and in so far as he is pure form, can know only the formal character of things, the concept of the Species, but never an individual, for an individual is always a combination of form and matter.

The World of matter is co-eternal with God. Having no will or desire, He can neither create nor reveal Himself to man. He is the goal of this world and not its cause. In so far as man approaches moral perfection, which is but another form of intellectual perfection, he approaches God, but God, who contains all perfection and desires nothing, never communicates with man. He therefore cannot be the active

source of inspiration or revelation, just as he cannot be the Creator of the physical world.

The king's vision however had been a vivid religious experience, in which he was conscious that God desired him to act rightly and that he had revealed a religion which he wished him to seek. The speech of the philosopher is therefore unsatisfying.

The Christian and Mohammedan agreeupon one thing; they both seek authorization for their founders in the revelationto Israel. It therefore becomes clear tothe king that he must find out from theJew himself the history of this revelation.

The grounds upon which the Jew bases his religious philosophy will seem unwarrantably dogmatic, unless we keep clearly in mind the intellectual atmosphere in which the author moved.

The chronology of the Bible and facts described as miracle were never thought to be other than authentic narrative. The rationalist tried to give them a rational explanation, the mystic would allegorize them, the scoffer tried to show that they were a clever deception, but all agreed that they were historically true. The idea of sacred legend had not entered to complicate Biblical interpretation. Jehudah Halevi does no more than accept the premises of his opponents when he makes the Biblical account of revelation the starting-point of his discussion.

In one respect however Jehudah Halevi is opposed to the prevailing current of thought. Following the reactionary tendency of Gazzali, the Mohammedan theologian, he tried to stem the rising tide of Aristotelianism.

The tendency was already very strong in Jewish circles to regard Aristotle and his philosophy as authoritative in the fields of philosophical thought. We know that in Christian scholasticism as well as in the Jewish philosophy which reached its highest fruition in Maimonides, the figure of Aristotle became intellectually dominant. The great problem with Maimonides was