The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 2 · August 1906
83printed page
scan 25 of 48

a forbedingung of a Jewish state it was natural for the S. S. to have become Territorialists as they did become.

More national and more logical are thePoaley-Zion Territorialists of the so-called“Minsk” school. Their standpoint is notdogmatically Marxistic, and out of thisarises the difference between them and theS. S. They admit materialism to be theprincipal factor in history, and the historyof the world to be the history of the struggle of class against class. Yet, besides thisclass of struggles, they maintain, there isdistinguishable another kind of strugglefor interests common to all classes of thevarious groups of people, called Nationalities.

Moreover, this latter class of struggles is assuming such forms which tend not only to assume the existence of each individual as such; but also to safeguard his interests as a member of the nation to which he belongs. In other words, it assumes such forms as tend toward safeguarding the existence of the different nationalities and their national and cultural values, which have been created by all classes commonly.

Taking this national-socialistic view, theZionist school of S. T. does not reach Territorialism from the theory of proletarisa-tion but from the economico-national pointof view. It is, indeed, in the interest ofthe Jewish proletariat, to create a nationaleconomy of its own, in order to receiveits existence as a class; but it has, at thesame time, also its national and culturalvalues to defend, an interest common toit and the burgeois class, with whomit can go hand in hand in the creationof a national center.

This centre need not, however, necessarily be Palestine; for, it is absurd, they maintain—and here they superficially hold up to ridicule the cry of the Zionist demagogue, but not that of the Zionist leaders—it is absurd to speak of a historical claim on Palestine, a claim that is justified neither from the legal point of view, because Palestine is now politically ruled by others, nor from the socialistic point of

view, because it is economically in the hands of other people.

The third important party of Socialist-Territorialists is the "Vozrozhdentzy" (Revivalists). This party is formed upon the principles of the Russian Socialist-Revolutionaries. In their nationalism they are fully in accord with the Minsk school, and they go in it perhaps even farther than the latter, for there is a touch of Achad-Haamism or Dubnovism in their national theories.The Vozrozhdentzy differ, however, from the other parties, in that they lay more stress upon the Gegenwarts program of the Jews in Russia. This, the Vozrozhdentzy were the first to take into their program; and now that the Gegenwarts program began to play an important part among all Zionist parties, the V. went to the extreme of declaring themselves for a Jewish "Seym" in Russia. The Seym, or Diet, is the latest claim put up by the Jewish nationalists in Austria and Russia, based upon the demands of the different nationalities in these countries to be recognized by their respective government not as political parties but as nationalities and to be given national autonomies of their own. And the V., together with other Jewish parties, putting up the same demand for the Jewish people, look forward to a Seym, which should serve for the Jews the purpose of a parliament to manage their own national affairs. And into the hands of this Seym the V. now propose to lay the Jewish future; for the Seym, controlling the spiritual and the material resources as it will, will be in position to decide whether the Jews should strive towards a territory of their own or should remain as a separate cultural body in the diaspora.

These are the different currents of ideas running through the Socialist-Territorialist movement in Russia. There remains for me here to say a word or two regarding the American Socialist-Territorialists. This organization has no prophets or theorists of its own. It has to import its ideas and theories from abroad; but in their make-up the American S. T. belong,