Col. Conder's Views on Zionism
To the December issue of Blackwood’s Magazine, Colonel Conder contributes an article on the Zionist question. The Jews, he says, like other nations, include many ciasses whose interest and ideals differ, and many schools of thought due to a narrower or a wider experience. The Polish Jew he regards as the lowest type of the race, though in this case one can detect “the bright eye and the energetic under-lip, which show that the old vigor of the race still lies concealed behind the humble cringing manner of the persecuted and destitute Ashkenazi.” The Polish Jews, says Colonel Conder, are intensely ignorant and superstitious, but not-without their ideal of a better future. Fe .
Amid sordid surroundings and engrossing anxieties they stil! nourish a belief in a happy time to come, when Israel shall rest under its vines and fig-trees in Palestine; and their aspiration still is, “Next year in Jerusalem.” The ancient vitality of the race is not exhausted, and in Palestine itself, where a second generation has grown up under more healthy conditions in agricultural colonies, the improvement in type and character has already become marked.
At the opposite end of the scale is the cultivated and highly-educated upper class, which, especially in England, is the product of a few centuries of freedom and prosperity. Between the extremes, says Colonel Conder, lie middle classes who, like the similar ranks in English society, he states are neither enthusiastic nor moderately intelligent, who pride themselves on being practical and whose imagination cannot conceive the burning wrath and sorrow which sear the hearts of the poor in lands where tyranny and hatred are concentrated in the deliberate attempt to crush the Hebrew. “It is for this middle-class that the greater part of the Jewish press in England caters. It prides itself on common-sense, and it looks coldly upon the enthusiast.” Continuing this not altogether just refer-
ence to the Jewish middle-class, he writes—
The middle-class Jew with whom Mr. Zangwill has made us well acquainted, may be either an orthodox disciple of his rabbis or may be a materialist who knows nothing of his own Scriptures, and who conforms to the customs of his society, while believing nothing and immersed in the pursuit of riches. Such men are the despair of those ‘who seek to raise the nation to higher ideals, and the hatred of the race in Europe has been in great measure due to the mean eraft of those who regard the Gentiles as lawful prey. Ancient memories of wrong have created this feeling of enmity to the foreigners among whom Israe! is forced to live, and pride of race has been distorted into a narrow conceit; while the Goim, who perish like the beast, are thought to have been created by Jehovah solely for the benefitt of the Jew.:
But among the higher class of those broad-minded Jews (adds Colonel Conder) who sincerely believe in their ancient religion, and who remember the precept of the Pentateuch which bids every Jew to "love his neighbor as himself," very noble efforts are made not only to help the poor and stem the tide of persecution, but also to raise the tone of the nation by appeal to the ancient memories and ideals. These people believe that the nation can only be raised from its misery by the creation of a national centre.
movement. The closing of Palestine to the Jews by the Sultan, he believes, was neither unreasonable nor damaging to the Zionist cause. Time was allowed for the absorption of a mass of destitute Jews who, by extraordinary exertions, began to make a living, aided by their societies. Time also has allowed the dissipation of that suspicion which was aroused among the Turks by the apparently political aspect of Dr. Herzl’s proposa!s. Turning to the Territorial alternative, which was then offered in East Africa, Col. Conder quotes the hos-