The Zionist Observer
THE BIG PROGRAM
At the end of the Day of Atonement it is often more easy to continue the fast than to break it—the fact applies to other habits than fasting. It is somewhere near two years since the writer retired from the skirmishing line of the Zionist struggle and the appeal to emerge from the retired list is met with difficulty. The advent in America of Dr. Shmaryahu Lewin facilitates but does not ease it. Much has happened since Herzl's death—that epoch in Jewish history—much that merely proved the absence of that giant mind.
The Zionist movement as created by Herzl has passed brought a variety of experiences. The big incidents of Jewish history were the Dreyfus affair, the Roumanian persecutions and the Kishinef massacre. Neither of these three events, nor the lesser events that crowded the years between 1896 and 1904, made suflicient of an immediate impression on the Jews to find them really ready for the emergency of a solution of the Jewish problem. The realisation of experience is never immediate: There is an infinitesimal pause between a blow and its registration in the nerves, and the people are but as an individual—only slower. Herzl knew this so well that he made little or no propaganda of the facts as they happened. He used these merely as new illustrations of a record on which he based the need for Zionism. To him, too, the future was paramount. He saw dangers and troubles ahead, and he endeavored to leglislate for them in advance. Many of his suggestions have gradually become commonp!:ace facts, though not one of his ideas have been applied with that perfeetion that he desired. So the record stands.
Since his death realisation has come. By this we do not mean that sentimental recognition of the man which was denied him
in life and which is becoming the platitude of many platforms otherwise anti-Zionistic. The Jewish consciousness, slow to grasp that its experiences were more than transitory, has been quickened by the infamous Odessa massacres, Bialystok and Siedlice, and by their consequences. For Herzl spoke the truth for all time when he said we carry anti-Semitism with us and its public avowal is merely a question of the Jewish proportion to general population. The combination of perspective and new experience has resulted in diverse but noteworthy results. It has created the I. T. O; a cross between the IKA, Philanthropy and Zionistic politics; it has bred the many qualified forms of the Zionist movement which admire the picture but quarrel about the frame; it has practically nationalised its German Jewry in Germany; it has engulfed the whole of English Jewry in such form that practically no one is astride the fence on the state question; the difference is one of Zion or anywhere else. It has forced a growth of Jewish democracy in the United States, which has only been warded off by the creation of the American Jewish Committe; it has, incidentally put reform on the defensive and has, moreover, compelled every Jewish commmunity of importance to think how best to double its finances. It has resulted in the Jewish political party in Galicia, which has the support. of the London Times and has almost brought about a grouping of the Jewish members of the English Parliament. In Russia, it has compelled the revolutionists to play at Jewish Nationalism and has destroyed the Bund because it was not sufficiently national. And this is but a rough outline of the bigger events of these two passing years, the details of which, though numerous, all point in one given direction.